John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 18 September 1823
From John Adams
Quincy September 18th 1823.
Dear Sir.
With much pleasure I have heard read the sure words of prophecy in your letter of Sep—4th. It is melancholy to contemplate the cruel wars, dessolations of Countries, and oceans1 of blood which must occur,2 before rational principles, and rational systems of Government can prevail and be established—but as these are inevitable we must content ourselves with the consolations which you from sound and sure reasons so clearly suggest—These3 hopes are as well founded as our fears of4 the contrary evils,—on the whole, the prospect is cheering;—I have lately undertaken to read Algernon Sidney on Government.5 there is a great difference in reading a Book at four and twenty, and at Eighty Eight, as often as I have read it, and fumbled it over; It now excites fresh admiration, that this work has excited so little interest in the literary world—As splendid an Edition of it, as the art of printing can produce, as well as for the intrinsick merit of the work, as for the proof it brings of the bitter sufferings of the advocates of Liberty from that time to this, and to show the slow progress of moral phylosophical political Illumination in the world ought to be now published in America.
It is true that Mr Jay. Mr Dickinson, and Mr Johnson, contributed to retard many vigorous measures, and particularly the vote of Independence untill he6 left Congress, but I have reason to think he would have concurred7 in that vote when it was taken if he had been there, His absence was accidental—
Congress on the fifteenth of May preceeding, as I remember had recommended to all the States to abolish all authority under the Crown, and institute and organize a new government under the Authority of the People—Mr Jay had promoted this resolution in New York by adviseing them to call a Convention to frame a new Constitution, he had been chosen a member of that Convention, and called home by his Constituents to assist in it—And as Duane told me he had gone home with [my]8 Letter to Wythe9 in his pocket for his model and foundation, and the same Duane after the Constitution appeared asked me if it was not sufficiently conformable to my letter to Wythe, I answered him I believed it would do very well, Mr Jay was immediately appointed Chief Justice of the State, and obliged to enter immediately on the duties of his Office, which occasioned his detention from Congress afterwards, but I have no doubt, had he been in Congress at the time he would have subscribed to the Declaration of Independence, he would have been neither recalled by his Constituents nor have left Congress himself, like Mr Dickinson, Mr Willing, Governor Livingston, and several others—
[warmly]10 as I feel for the spanish Patriots I fear the most sensible Men among them have little confidence in their Constitution which appears to me is modeled upon that in France of the Year 1789. in which the sovereignty11 in a single assembly was every thing and the executive nothing, the Spaniards have adopted all this, with the singular addition that the members of the Cortes can serve only two years, what rational being can have any well grounded confidence in such a Constitution—
As you write so easy, and so well, I pray you to write me as often as possible, for nothing revives my spirits so much as your letters, except the society of my Son and his Family, who are now happily with me after an absence of two Years—
John Adams
RC (DLC); entirely in Louisa C. Smith’s hand; endorsed by TJ as received 29 Sept. 1823 and so recorded in SJL; with notation by TJ beneath endorsement: “see Boston Patriot June 12 24.” RC (DLC); address cover only; with FC of TJ to Stephen Van Rensselaer, 20 Feb. 1825, on verso; addressed in Smith’s hand: “Thomas Jefferson. late President of the United States. Monticello—Virginia”; franked; postmarked Quincy, 18 Sept. FC (Lb in MHi: Adams Papers); in Smith’s hand; dated 17 Sept. 1823. Printed as a letter of 17 Sept. 1823 in Salem Essex Register, 10 June 1824, Independent Chronicle and Boston Patriot, 12 June 1824, and elsewhere.
The Continental Congress approved a resolution to institute and organize a new government under the authority of the people on 10 May 1776. Five days later a preamble was added stating that “the exercise of every kind of authority under the said crown should be totally suppressed” (Worthington C. Ford and others, eds., Journals of the Continental Congress, 1774–1789 [1904–37], 4:342, 357–8).
Adams’s letter to wythe was a set of suggestions on how to establish a representative government that he composed originally late in March 1776 at the request of two delegates from North Carolina. He then copied and revised it at the request of George Wythe, and in this form it was published as Thoughts on Government: Applicable to The Present State of the American Colonies. In a Letter from a Gentleman To his Friend (Philadelphia, 1776; Sowerby, no. 3124). All three extant versions are printed in Robert J. Taylor and others, eds., Papers of John Adams (1977– ), 4:65–93.
Article 110 of the 1812 Spanish constitution stipulated that members of the cortes “cannot be elected to serve a second time until another election has intervened” (Constitution of the Spanish Monarchy. Promulgated at Cadiz on the 19th of March, 1812 [Philadelphia, 1814; Sowerby, no. 2424], 18).
1. RC and FC: “ocians.” Newspapers: “oceans.”
2. RC: “occure.” FC and newspapers: “occur.”
3. RC and FC: “Thes.” Newspapers: “These.”
4. RC: “of of.”
5. Omitted period supplied from newspapers.
6. Independent Chronicle here includes “(Mr. Jay).”
7. RC and FC: “concured.” Newspapers: “concurred.”
8. RC: “his.” Reworked in FC from “his” to “my.” Newspapers: “my.”
9. RC and FC: “Withe.” Newspapers: “Wythe.”
10. RC: “Nearly.” FC and newspapers: “warmly.” In FC and newspapers, paragraph starting with this word written beneath signature as a postscript.
11. RC and FC: “soverignty.” Newspapers: “Sovereignty.”
12. Word not in FC or newspapers.
Index Entries
- Adams, John; and Declaration of Independence search
- Adams, John; and democratic revolutions search
- Adams, John; and J. Jay search
- Adams, John; correspondence with G. Wythe search
- Adams, John; family of search
- Adams, John; letters from search
- Adams, John; on Spanish constitution search
- Adams, John; reading habits of search
- Adams, John; Thoughts on Government: Applicable to The Present State of the American Colonies search
- Adams, John Quincy; family of search
- Adams, John Quincy; relationship with J. Adams search
- American Revolution; J. Adams on search
- books; on government search
- Continental Congress, Second; and Declaration of Independence search
- Continental Congress, Second; organizes new government search
- Declaration of Independence; debate on search
- Dickinson, John; and Continental Congress search
- Discourses concerning Government (A. Sidney) search
- Duane, James; as member of Continental Congress search
- France; Constitution of1791 search
- Jay, John; and Continental Congress search
- Jay, John; and N.Y. constitution search
- Jay, John; as chief justice of N.Y. search
- Jay, John; J. Adams on search
- Johnson, Thomas (of Maryland); as member of Continental Congress search
- Livingston, William; as member of Continental Congress search
- New York (state); constitution of search
- politics; books on government search
- Sidney, Algernon; Discourses concerning Government search
- Sidney, Algernon; read by J. Adams search
- Smith, Louisa Catharine (John Adams’s niece); as J. Adams’s amanuensis search
- Spain; constitution of search
- Spain; Cortes of search
- Thoughts on Government: Applicable to The Present State of the American Colonies (J. Adams) search
- Willing, Thomas; as member of Continental Congress search
- Wythe, George; correspondence with J. Adams search