Thomas Jefferson to John Adams, 4 September 1823
To John Adams
Monticello Sep. 4. 23.
Dear Sir
Your letter of Aug. 15. was recieved in due time, and with the welcome of every thing which comes from you. with it’s opinions on the difficulties of revolutions, from despotism to freedom, I very much concur. the generation which commences a revolution can rarely compleat1 it. habituated from their infancy to passive submission of body and mind to their kings and priests, they are not qualified, when called on, to think and provide for themselves and their inexperience, their ignorance and bigotry make them instruments often, in the hands of the Bonapartes and Iturbides to defeat their own rights and purposes. this is the present situation of Europe and Spanish America. but it is not desperate. the light which has been shed on mankind by the art of printing has eminently changed the condition of2 the world. as yet that light has dawned on the midling classes only3 of the men of Europe. the kings and the rabble of equal ignorance, have not yet recieved it’s rays; but it continues to spread and, while printing is preserved, it can no more recede than the sun return on his course. a first attempt to recover the right of self-government may fail; so may a 2d a 3d Etc. but as a younger, and more instructed race comes on, the sentiment becomes more and more intuitive, and a 4th a 5th or some subsequent one of the ever renewed attempts will ultimately succeed. in France the 1st effort was defeated by Robespierre, the 2d by Bonaparte, the 3d by Louis XVIII. and his holy allies; another is yet to come, and all Europe, Russia excepted, has caught the spirit, and all will attain representative government, more or less perfect. this is now well understood to be a necessary check on kings, whom they will probably think it more prudent to chain and tame, than to exterminate. to attain all this however rivers of blood must yet flow, & years of desolation pass over. yet the object is worth rivers of blood, and years of desolation for what inheritance so valuable can man leave to his posterity? the spirit of the Spaniard and his deadly and eternal hatred to a Frenchman, gives me much confidence that he will never submit, but finally defeat this atrocious violation of the laws of god and man under which he is suffering; and the wisdom and firmness of the Cortes afford reasonable hope that that nation will settle down in a temperate representative government, with an Executive properly subordinated to that. Portugal, Italy, Prussia, Germany, Greece will follow suit. you and I shall look down from another world on these glorious atchievements to man, which will add to the joys even of heaven.
I observe your toast of mr Jay on the 4th of July, wherein you say that the omission of his signature to the Declaration of Independance was by accident. our impressions as to this fact being different, I shall be glad to have mine corrected, if wrong. Jay, you know, had been in constant opposition to our laboring majority. our estimate, at the time, was that he, Dickinson & Johnson of Maryland by their ingenuity, perseverance and partiality to our English connection, had constantly kept us a year behind where we ought to have been in our preparations and proceedings. from about the date of the Virginia instructions of May 15. 76. to declare Independance4 mr Jay absented himself from Congress, and never came there again until Dec. 78. of course he had no part in the discussions or decision of that question. the instructions to their delegates by the Convention of New York, then sitting, to sign the Declaration, were presented to Congress on the 15th of July only, and on that day the journals shew the absence of mr Jay by a letter recieved from him, as they had done as early as the 29th of May by another letter. and, I think, he had been omitted by the Convention on a new election of Delegates when they changed their instructions. of this last fact however having no evidence but an antient impression, I shall not affirm it. but whether so or not, no agency of accident appears in the case. this error of fact however, whether yours or mine, is of little consequence to the public. but truth being as cheap as error, it is as well to rectify it for our own satisfaction.
I have had a fever of about three weeks during the last and preceding month, from which I am entirely recovered except as to strength. ever and affectionately yours
Th: Jefferson
RC (MHi: Adams Papers); addressed: “John Adams Ex-president of the US. Quincy Mass.”; franked; postmarked Charlottesville, 8 Sept. PoC (DLC); edge trimmed.
In a toast to John Jay at the 4 July 1823 Independence Day celebration in Quincy, Adams praised “The excellent President, Governor, Ambassador, and Chief-Justice John Jay, whose name by accident, was not subscribed to the Declaration of Independence, as it ought to have been; for he was one of its ablest and faithfullest supporters—A splendid Star just setting below the horizon” (Boston Columbian Centinel, 12 July 1823). For the 15 May 1776 virginia instructions to its delegates in the Continental Congress, see PTJ, 1:290–1.
Jay was chosen as one of New York’s delegates to the First Continental Congress in 1774. Renamed to that role for the Second Continental Congress in 1775, he later became its president. After an absence from Congress in May and July 1776, he presented new credentials from New York at his return in dec. 78 (ANB; Worthington C. Ford and others, eds., Journals of the Continental Congress, 1774–1789 [1904–37], 4:403, 5:559, 560, 12:1196–7).
1. Reworked from “revolution rarely compleats,” with PoC left unrevised.
2. TJ here canceled “man.”
3. Reworked from “midling class.”
4. Preceding three words added separately in margins of RC and PoC.
Index Entries
- Adams, John; and democratic revolutions search
- Adams, John; and J. Jay search
- Adams, John; letters to search
- Continental Congress, First; members of search
- Continental Congress, Second; and Declaration of Independence search
- Continental Congress, Second; members of search
- Declaration of Independence; signers of search
- Dickinson, John; opposes declaring independence search
- Europe; revolutions in search
- Fourth of July; celebrations search
- France; and invasion of Spain (1823) search
- France; TJ on search
- Holy Alliance; mentioned search
- Iturbide, Agustín de (later Agustín I, emperor of Mexico) search
- Jay, John; and Continental Congress search
- Jay, John; J. Adams on search
- Jefferson, Thomas; Health; fever search
- Jefferson, Thomas; Opinions on; democratic revolutions search
- Jefferson, Thomas; Opinions on; France search
- Johnson, Thomas (of Maryland); as member of Continental Congress search
- Louis XVIII, king of France; as counterrevolutionary search
- Napoleon I, emperor of France; mentioned search
- printing; TJ on importance of search
- Robespierre, Maximilien François Marie Isidore de; as leader of French Revolution search
- Spain; Cortes of search
- Spain; invaded by France (1823) search
- Spain; revolution in search