Abiel Holmes to Thomas Jefferson, 17 March 1823
From Abiel Holmes
Cambridge (Mass.) 17 March 1823.
Sir,
By the encouragement and aid you were pleased to give me in preparing the American Annals for publication, I am emboldened to ask your advice in reference to another edition, which I am preparing for the press. One of the English Reviews, while, with other foreign Journals, sufficiently honouring the work with its commendation, suggests, that it had better have begun with the English colonization, and restricted itself to Anglo-American history. It early appeared to me desirable, to have a thread to guide us through the entire history of this New World. It was the want of one for myself, that induced me to form chronological tables, commencing with the time of the discovery of America, and extending to our own times. These were afterwards filled out, and published as Chronological History—a method of historical writing of which you spoke in commendation, as practised in Europe. I have not found sufficient reason to alter the original plan; for it appears to me best adapted to satisfy those, who would wish to obtain some general knowledge of this Western Continent. We enter with more delight and interest, upon the adventures and settlements of our own nation, when we have observed what had been previously done by other nations. On that prior history I was very concise; nor am I sure that it could be advantageously abridged.
It has occurred to me, however, that, as every thing material in that portion of the work closes just at the time of Sir Walter Ralegh’s patent, it will be an improvement, to divide the volumes into books, or chapters, and to conclude all that pertains to Spanish America with the first book, or chapter. The second may embrace the years from the patent for Virginia to the settlement of Massachusetts; the third, to the conquest of New York by the English; the fourth, to the Revolution of William & Mary; the fifth, to the settlement of Georgia; the sixth, to the Peace of 1763; the seventh, to the Declaration of Independence; the eighth, to the adoption of the Federal Constitution; and the ninth, to the present time. This extension of the work, and an enlargement on many articles in the first edition, will require an additional volume; and the three volumes, if three books, or chapters, be assigned to each volume, will be proportionate to each other.
My design is, to be more full and particular from 1765 to the American Revolution; and from 1783 to the present time; and to give a more distinct view of the causes, the principles, and the agents of our glorious Revolution, and of the characteristic features of our governments and institutions. On the last of these topics I shall avail myself of the lucid exposition, presented in your Inaugural Address, which, if duly regarded, will, under Divine Providence, ensure the stability and prosperity of our united and happy Republic.
From the Library of the late Professor Ebeling of Hamburg, and from other sources, I am enabled to make what, I hope, will be useful additions to some articles in our early history; for the later periods I shall rely on official documents. I have in my possession the American State Papers; and shall also have recourse to the Journals of Congress, and the Laws of the United States.
Might I be favoured, Sir, with your indication of other authorities for what pertains to the United States, or to any individual State, from the commencement of the Revolution, and with your judgment on my proposed alterations, I should gratefully acknowledge my additional obligation to you. Original communications, or papers not in our possession, relating to Virginia, desirous as I am to do justice to that ancient and highly respected State, I dare not ask. The lapse of nearly forty seven years since you penned the Declaration of Independence, and the recent notice of your infirmities in your letter to President Adams, admonish me to stop here. If I have already gone too far, your benevolence, I persuade myself, will pardon what proceeded from my respect to your character, and my desire to promote the cause of Truth, and the interests of our Country.
Should the infirm hand, which signed our Magna Charta, be so far recovered, as to give your own signature to an answer, however short, I should feel myself greatly honoured and obliged by it, and preserve it as a valued and perpetual memorial. In any case, it is my intention to make a public acknowledgment of my great obligations to you for the loan of the Memoires de l’Amerique—a very important work, which I should not otherwise have seen, from which I have made large extracts, of which I shall now make considerable use.
Abiel Holmes.
RC (DLC); between dateline and salutation: “To the Honr Thomas Jefferson”; mistakenly endorsed by TJ as received 3 Mar. 1823, but recorded in SJL as received 3 Apr. 1823.
Abiel Holmes (1763–1837), Congregational minister and historian, was born in Woodstock, Connecticut. He graduated from Yale College (later Yale University) in 1783 and served as a tutor there, 1786–87. Having been ordained in 1785, both before and after his tutorship Holmes ministered to a Congregational church in Midway, Liberty County, Georgia. In 1791 he returned north, serving as pastor of the First Church in Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1792–1829. Holmes published The Life of Ezra Stiles, D.D., LL.D., a biography of his late father-in-law, in Boston in 1798. He followed this with American Annals; or a chronological History of America from its discovery in MCCCCXCII to MDCCCVI, 2 vols. (Cambridge, Mass., 1805; , no. 444). Holmes served as corresponding secretary of the Massachusetts Historical Society, 1813–33, and he was elected to the American Philosophical Society in 1816. Amidst the rise of Unitarianism, the more orthodox Holmes and a large portion of his congregation split from First Church in 1829 and formed a new society, at which he officiated until his retirement in 1831. The father of the poet Oliver Wendell Holmes, the elder Holmes died in Cambridge ( ; , 4:277–85; William B. Sprague, Annals of the American Pulpit [1857–69], 2:240–6; , esp. 44:551–2; , Minutes, 18 Oct. 1816 [MS in PPAmP]; gravestone inscription in Mount Auburn Cemetery, Cambridge).
TJ gave Holmes encouragement and aid for his American Annals in a letter of 7 Dec. 1804 ( , 45:140–1). In his first inaugural address on 4 Mar. 1801, TJ outlined “the essential principles of our government, and consequently those which ought to shape its administration” ( , 33:150–1). TJ’s letter to president adams was dated 1 June 1822.
In 1807 TJ loaned Holmes his copy of Étienne de Silhouette and others, eds., Mémoires des Commissaires du Roi et de ceux de sa Majesté Britannique, Sur les possessions & les droits respectifs des deux Couronnes en Amérique (memoires de l’amerique), 4 vols. (Paris, 1755–57; , no. 1452). Holmes returned it the following year (TJ to Holmes, 20 Mar. 1807 [MHi]; Holmes to TJ, 9 Nov. 1808 [DLC]). Holmes eventually used this work and thanked TJ for its loan in the preface to his second edition, renamed The Annals of America, from the discovery by Columbus in the Year 1492, to the Year 1826, 2 vols. (1829), v.
Index Entries
- Adams, John; and publication of TJ’s letters search
- American Annals; or, a Chronological History of America, from its discovery in 1492 to 1806 (A. Holmes) search
- American Philosophical Society; members of search
- American Revolution; books on search
- books; of state papers and public documents search
- books; on history search
- Constitution, U.S.; mentioned search
- Declaration of Independence; mentioned search
- Declaration of Independence; signers of search
- Declaration of Independence; TJ as author of search
- Ebeling, Christoph Daniel; library of search
- Holmes, Abiel; American Annals; or, a Chronological History of America, from its discovery in 1492 to 1806 search
- Holmes, Abiel; identified search
- Holmes, Abiel; letter from search
- Holmes, Abiel; The Annals of America, from the discovery by Columbus in the Year 1492, to the Year 1826 search
- House of Representatives, U.S.; journals of search
- Jefferson, Thomas; Health; wrist injury search
- Jefferson, Thomas; Writings; Declaration of Independence search
- Jefferson, Thomas; Writings; First Inaugural Address search
- Mary II, queen of Great Britain; reign of search
- Mémoires des Commissaires du Roi et de ceux de sa Majesté Britannique, Sur les possessions & les droits respectifs des deux Couronnes en Amérique (É. de Silhouette) search
- Paris; Treaty of (1763) search
- Raleigh, Sir Walter search
- Senate, U.S.; journals of search
- Silhouette, Étienne de; Mémoires des Commissaires du Roi et de ceux de sa Majesté Britannique, Sur les possessions & les droits respectifs des deux Couronnes en Amérique search
- The Annals of America, from the discovery by Columbus in the Year 1492, to the Year 1826 (A. Holmes) search
- United States; state papers and public documents search
- William III, king of Great Britain; reign of search