From Rufus Putnam
Marietta [Northwest Territory] Januy 8th 1791.
The mischief which I feared, has overtaken us much sooner than I expected. On the Evening of the 2d instant, between sunset and daylight-in; the indians supprised a new settlement of our people at a place on the Muskingum, called the Big-bottom, near forty miles up the river, in which disaster eleven men,1 one woman, and two children, were killed: Three men are missing—and four others made their Escape.2 Thus, sir, the war, which was partial before the campaign of last year, is, in all probability, become general: For, I think there is no reason to suppose that we are the only people on whom the savages will wreak their vengeance, or that the number of hostile indians have not encreased since the late expedition.3 Our situation is truly critical: The governor and secretary both being absent; no assistance from Virginia or Pennsylvania can be had. The garrison at Fort Harmar, consisting at this time of little more than twenty men,4 can afford no protection to our settlements And the whole number of men, in all our settlements, capable of bearing arms, including all civil and military officers, do not exceed two hundred and eighty seven, and these, many of them, badly armed. We are in the utmost danger of being swallowed up should the Enemy push the war with vigor during the winter; this I belive will fully appear, by taking a short view of our several settlements, and I hope justify the extraordinary measures we have adopted, for want of a legal authority in the territory to apply to for aid in the business. The situation of our people is nearly as follows:
At Marietta are about eighty houses, in the distance of one mile, with scattering houses about three miles up the Ohio. A set of mills at Duck creek, four miles distant, and another mill, two miles 5 up the Muskingum. Twenty two miles up this river is a settlement, consisting of about twenty families⟨;⟩ about two miles from them, on Wolf Creek, are five families and a set of mills.6 Down the Ohio, and opposite the Little Kenahawa, commences the settlement called Belle prairie, which extends down the river, with little interruption, about twelve miles, and contains between thirty and forty houses.7 Before the late disaster, we had several other settlements, which are alredy broken up. I have taken the liberty to enclose the proceedings of the Ohio company and Justices of the sessions on this occasion, and beg leave, with the greatest deference, to observe, that, unless government speedily send a body of troops for our protection, we are a ruined people. The removal of the women and children, &c., will reduce many of the poorer sort to the greatest straits; but, if we add to this the destruction of their corn, forage, and cattle, by the enemy, which is very probable to ensue, I know of no way, they can be supported; but, if this should not happen, where these people are to raise bread another year, is not easy to conjecture, and most of them have nothing left to buy with. But my fears do not stop here; we are a people so far detached from all others, in point of situation that we can hope for no timely relief, in case of emergency, from any of our neighbours: and, among the number that compose our present military strength, almost one half are young men, hired into the country, intending to settle by and by;8 these, under present circumstances, will probably leave us soon,9 unless prospects should brighten; and, as to new settlers, we can expect none in our present situation; so that, instead of encreasing in strength, we are like to diminish daily; & if we do not fall a prey to the savages, we shall be so reduced and discouraged as to give up the settlement, unless Government shall give us timely protection. It has been a mystery with some, why the troops have been with drawn from this quarter, and collected at the Miami; that settlement, is, I believe, within10 three or four day’s march of a very populous part of Kentuckey, from whence, in a few days, they might be reinforced with several thousand men: Whereas, we are not within two hundred miles of any settlement, that can probably more than protect themselves.
But, I forbear suggestions of this sort, and will only observe further, that our present situation is truly distressing; and I do, therefore, most earnestly implore the protection of Government, for myself and friends inhabiting these wilds of America. To this we conceive our-selves justly entitled; and, so far as you, Sir, have the means in your power,11 we rest assured that we shall receive it in due time. I have the honor to be, with the highest possible respect, Sir, Your most obedient and most humble servant,
Copy, DNA: RG 46, First Congress, 1789–1791, Records of Executive Proceedings, President’s Messages; copy, OMC: Manasseh Cutler Papers; copy, NHi: Henry O’Reilly Collection. There are many minor differences in wording between the copies at DNA and NHi and that at OMC. Substantive differences have been noted.
1. The copy at OMC reads “14 men.”
2. On the evening of 2 Jan. 1791, a party of about twenty-five Wyandots and Delawares attacked the American settlement at Big Bottom on the Muskingum River, some thirty miles north of the confluence of the Muskingum and the Ohio. This settlement had been established by associates of the Ohio Company the previous autumn. The settlers, mostly young men, had failed to post sentries and were taken entirely by surprise. The Indians killed twelve of the thirteen people in the main blockhouse, including one woman and two children, and took the lone survivor of the group, a teenage boy, captive. The raiders also captured four others in a cabin north of the blockhouse. The two occupants of a cabin south of the blockhouse fled into the woods and escaped. The raiders piled the dead bodies in the blockhouse and set fire to the structure, which was constructed of green beech logs. The fire only charred the interior before burning out, leaving the partially burned remains of the victims to be found by a rescue party, which arrived on 4 January. Members of this party found an Indian war club hanging at the scene as a symbolic declaration of war (Sword, Washington’s Indian War, description begins Wiley Sword. President Washington’s Indian War: The Struggle for the Old Northwest, 1790–1795. Norman, Okla., 1985. description ends 128–29). For further details and comments on this event, see Putnam to GW, 28 Feb. 1791. GW submitted this letter to Congress on 27 Jan. 1791, as further evidence of the critical condition of the frontiers (see GW to the U.S. Senate and House of Representatives, 27 Jan. 1791).
3. The words “since the late expedition” do not appear in the copy at OMC.
4. In the copy at OMC this phrase reads “of no more than 22 effectives rank and file.”
5. In the copy at OMC the words “from Marietta,” followed by a semicolon, appear at this point.
6. In the copy at OMC this portion of the sentence reads: “up the Muskingum 22 miles distant is a settlement of about 20 families; and on Wolf Creek about 18 miles from Marietta is a set of mills where are five families.”
7. According to the copy at OMC, “Belleprie . . . contains six block-houses and can muster about sixty fighting men.”
8. The copy at OMC reads: “and among the number that compose our present military strength there are more than 60 who are young men that have no real estate or interest in the country; most of them intending a settlement by and by.”
9. In the copy at OMC the words “as the people who employed them will not be able to carry on their plantations” are inserted here.
10. At this point the “in” was inadvertently repeated.
11. The copy at OMC concludes with the words “you will grant it.”