To James Madison
Mount Vernon May 2d 1788
My dear Sir,
Your favor of the 10th Ult. came duly to hand, and the enclosure for Mr D. Carroll was forwarded the next day by a direct & safe conveyance.1 That Gentleman, however, was not of the Convention. But the body of which you supposed him to be a member, by a large and decided Majority (of Sixty odd to twelve) have ratified the New Constitution. A thorn this in the sides of the leaders of opposition in this State. Should South Carolina give as unequivocal approbation of the system, the opposition here will become feeble; for eight affirmatives without a negative carries weight of argument, if not of eloquence along with it, which might cause even the unerring sister to hesitate.
Mr Chace, it is said, made a display of all his eloquence. Mr Mercer discharged his whole Artillery of inflamable matter—and Mr Martin did something—I know not what—but presume with vehemence—yet no converts were made—no, not one.2 so the business, after a very short Session, ended; and will if I mistake not, render yours less tiresome. With Sentiments of sincere regard & Affect. I am—Yours
ALS, MA; LB, DLC:GW.
1. Daniel Carroll on 28 April acknowledged receipt of Madison’s letter of 10 April, which has not been found (Rutland and Hobson, Madison Papers, description begins William T. Hutchinson et al., eds. The Papers of James Madison, Congressional Series. 17 vols. Chicago and Charlottesville, Va., 1962–91. description ends 11:21,30–31).
2. The ratifying convention met in Annapolis on 21 April and began debate on the Constitution itself on 23 April. Vote on ratification was taken on 24 April, sixty-three delegates voting for and eleven voting against. After agreeing to recommend a number of amendments, the convention adjourned on 29 April. John Francis Mercer and Luther Martin had both left the Federal Convention, and neither had signed the new Constitution.