George Washington Papers

John Armstrong to George Washington, 8 March 1781

From John Armstrong

Carlisle [Pa.] 8th March 1781

Dear General

Five Sabel months have passed Over Since I last had the pleasure of writing yr Excellency & then unable to finish a letter of moderate length, of which indispossion I am fully recovered,1 but having passed the Sixty third of my age, find little capacity for active life except in the dreams of an intoxicated immagination, which ought to be corrected & the thoughts turned upward; permit me Sir to wish your present years may be protracted not to any specified period, but as long as you can be serviceable to your country or comfortable to yourself.

This remote part of the country admiting but little news and being now out of the publick line of politicks, you will readily See the designe of the present to be only a memento of ancient & invariable friendship which ought not easily to be extinquished. At the Same time we may a little lament our present embarrasments without enveying against our rulers; but with greater pleasure observe the various dawnings of hope & assistance resulting from the divine government alone. As to the former your Excellency has but too many proofs of the complicated evils prevalent amongst us & a greater share of their consquent burthens than any but an enemy could wish—ignorance in the novel and Subtile business of finance, together with the want of an earlier reformation in the whole line of expenditure have been at the bottom of all our distresses; the latter however desireable cannot to any great purpose be accomplished until our money is reduced to some settled Standard, nor even then whilst the argument of Scarcity can possibly be introduced. we have also to regret that spurious kind of knowledge lately improven amongst us, known by the name of Speculation, but of worst kind the genuine offspring of Averice & pride. With respect to finance, it has been to us like the doubleings of an Eele, having brought Congress to their wits-end—that body in my opinion having long been involved in thick darkness unable to make any certain estimate of Success from natural resources or any arrangements they can make, must only draw a bow at adventure, or grope for the wall in the dark, Supporting their laudible hopes on the divine government in the justice of their cause; and here must we wish the mind of every virtuous American may humbly Center—without any relaxation of the natural means. On the other hand We have lately had Several favourable appearances from the South a Country not well Stored with military Supplys, and previously visited by a Series of misfortune or rather necessary chastisement—amongst these flattering prognosticks, the affair of Genl Morgan has been of the kind not only compleat, but attended with some circumstances clearly providential & manifestative of the divine favour on our part Such was the ease & Suddenty of the victory, the essential part of the conflict as some Say not lasting above ten minutes—the Safety of his retreat with the prisoners & interveneing rains in his favour;2 to these may we not venture to add the precipitate March of Genl Cornwallis for near two hundred miles, Genl Green retreating to better resources & the other leaving his behind, who if not supported by Genl Philips in his rear (as Some now say he is) cannot easily expect to return;3 hopeing as we do that the good people of N. Carolina & Virginia will observe the happy Opportunity presented to them. Fears are expressed for Genl Green, or that Cornwallis will form a junction with the Arch-traitor, but in either case are these fears groundless & the efforts rather to be desired4— the ground of apprehension if any there be is that a retreat may be attempted Similar to the pursuit, or what effect those new operations, loss of Strength and detachment of troops may have upon West Point. The Neutral Confederation in Europe has also a Salutary asspect5 & the approach and Success of our warm friend the Count De Estaigne if true, must greatly enliven our hopes6—Our Embarrasments are many, but the Lord reigns—would to God our Sentiments were more pure and our lives more conformable to his Government.

Recruiting in this part of the Country but begining requires more time to know the effect, and so mortifying is the affair of the Pennsylvania line & so crude the censures of some that I can only be Silent upon it.7

The complicated affliction of po⟨or⟩ Genl Gates, is really moving—we hear that on his return he found his house inhabited only by Servants, Mrs Gates having absented herself from the View of it after the death of her Son—and that they are very disconsolate8—He has Sent for Major Armstrong who but just recovering from a dangerous fever which was followed with a Cough & pain in his breast, has gone up to him—the General will probably Soon repair to Congress—from all I have heard of ⟨the illegible after⟩ the Subspention and order of tryal appears to have been ⟨illegible9 By a late report from the South it’s said that Genl Greene has Arrested Collo. Armong upon the representation or depossition of One or more officers of rank now prisoners at Charlestown, impeaching him of bad conduct on the 16th of August.10 I am dear General—with every Sentiment of gratitude & regard Your Excellencys most Obedt humble Servt

John Armstrong

ALS, DLC:GW. Armstrong wrote “To be forwarded by Coll Miles” on the cover. Armstrong presumably sent his letter to Samuel Miles, former colonel of the state rifle regiment who then served as deputy quartermaster general for Pennsylvania. GW replied to Armstrong on 26 March.

1Armstrong’s most recent extant letter to GW, dated 31 Aug. 1780, reported health concerns, the capture of American vessels in the West Indies, and information on southern operations.

2Armstrong refers to Brig. Gen. Daniel Morgan’s victory at the Battle of Cowpens on 17 Jan. (see Nathanael Greene’s first letter to GW, 24 Jan., and n.3 to that document).

The New-Jersey Gazette (Trenton) for 7 March printed an item datelined “PHILADELPHIA, February 28,” with news that Morgan’s troops “very judiciously made forced marches up into the country, and happily crossed the Catawba the evening before a great rain, which swelled the river to such a degree as prevented the enemy from crossing for several days, during which time the prisoners were got over the Yadkin.”

3Following the Battle of Cowpens, Lt. Gen. Charles Cornwallis pushed Maj. Gen. Nathanael Greene’s army from North Carolina into Virginia (see Greene to GW, 9, 15, and 28 Feb.; see also Steuben to GW, 12 Feb.).

Rather than supporting Cornwallis, Maj. Gen. William Phillips led an expedition to Virginia to reinforce Brig. Gen. Benedict Arnold (see Elias Dayton to GW, 9 and 15 March).

4Greene feared a junction of the forces under Cornwallis and Arnold (see Lafayette’s first letter to GW, 13 April, and n.3 to that document). Troops under Cornwallis later combined with those in Virginia under Phillips (see Lafayette to GW, 8 May, and Thomas Jefferson to GW, 9 May, both DLC:GW).

5Armstrong refers to the League of Armed Neutrality (see GW to Samuel Huntington, 6 July 1780, n.6).

6For the false report about a French naval victory in the West Indies involving Vice Admiral d’Estaing, see Rochambeau to GW, 18, 20, and 27 Feb. 1781. Another erroneous report claimed that d’Estaing had sailed for the United States (see Robert Hanson Harrison to GW, 14 April).

7For the mutiny in the Pennsylvania line and subsequent recruitment efforts, see Anthony Wayne to GW, 2 and 28 Jan., and Arthur St. Clair to GW, 2 March and 6 April; see also William Butler to Joseph Reed, 28 Feb., and William Henry to Reed, 3 March, in Pa. Archives description begins Samuel Hazard et al., eds. Pennsylvania Archives. 9 ser., 138 vols. Philadelphia and Harrisburg, 1852–1949. description ends , 1st ser., 8:747–48, 754.

8Maj. Gen. Horatio Gates and his wife, Elizabeth, grieved the loss of their son, Robert, who had died from illness on 4 Oct. 1780. Gates also faced uncertainty over his military career from a court of inquiry that Congress had ordered following his defeat at Camden, S.C., on 16 Aug. 1780. Once Greene assumed command of the southern army, Gates retired to his plantation in Berkeley County, Va. (see Gates to GW, 30 Aug. 1780, and n.1 to that document; GW to Nathanael Greene, 22 Oct. 1780, and n.5 to that document; Gates to GW, 15 Jan. 1781; and Nelson, General Horatio Gates description begins Paul David Nelson. General Horatio Gates: A Biography. Baton Rouge, La., 1976. description ends , 250–54).

Robert Gates (1758–1780), an only child, received an honorary degree from Harvard in 1779. For an assessment of the young man after a period of education in England, see Horatio Gates to William Byrd, 6 Oct. 1774, in Tinling, Byrd Correspondence description begins Marion Tinling, ed. The Correspondence of the Three William Byrds of Westover, Virginia, 1684–1776. 2 vols. Charlottesville, Va., 1977. description ends , 2:799–800.

Elizabeth Phillips Gates (c.1736–1783) had married in 1754.

9Maj. John Armstrong, Jr., who had served as Gates’s aide-de-camp since 1777, fell gravely ill with a fever (likely malaria) in summer 1780. He wrote Gates from Carlisle on 14 Jan. 1781 that the fever had persisted “’till about 3 Weeks ago” (Gregory and Dunnings, “Gates Papers” description begins James Gregory and Thomas Dunnings, eds. “Horatio Gates Papers, 1726–1828.” Sanford, N.C., 1979. Microfilm. description ends ). Armstrong, Jr., again wrote Gates on 13 March that “I shall be with you in some part of the next week” (Gregory and Dunnings, “Gates Papers” description begins James Gregory and Thomas Dunnings, eds. “Horatio Gates Papers, 1726–1828.” Sanford, N.C., 1979. Microfilm. description ends ). Armstrong, Jr., and Gates traveled to Philadelphia in April to address the latter’s court of inquiry. Congress repealed its resolution for an investigation in 1782 and authorized Gates to reassume an army command (see Huntington to GW, 26 April 1781, and n.3 to that document; Skeen, John Armstrong, Jr. description begins C. Edward Skeen. John Armstrong, Jr., 1758–1843: A Biography. Syracuse, N.Y., 1981. description ends , 7–8; and Nelson, General Horatio Gates description begins Paul David Nelson. General Horatio Gates: A Biography. Baton Rouge, La., 1976. description ends , 258–65).

10Armstrong conveyed erroneous intelligence. Colonel Armand received a furlough and traveled to France in February to procure clothing and arms for his legion (see GW to Armand, 12 Jan.). Armand’s legion had performed poorly at the Battle of Camden.

Index Entries