From Colonel David Forman
Prince Town [N.J.] 7th Novr 1777
Your Excelys favr of the 31st I recd the 1st Novr and The same Morning I recd an Answar from The Counsil of Safety to a Letter I had wrote to Govr Livingston Respecting The Conduct of Brgr Genl Newcomb—The Counsil of safety in their Letter to me enclosed one for Genl Newcomb which they assured me contain’d Their orders to him to make me returns of his Brigade and receive my orders—I Immediately sent a Horsman to Genl Newcomb with The Letter, but recd no kind of Answar from him—I then wrote a Note requesting him to furnish a Number of Men to Mount Certain Guards as Will Necessary to insure early intilligence of The Enemies movements should They make a second Decent on this Shoar as to prevent a Communication with the Enemy, and sent Lieut. Colol Laurance with it to Genl Newcomb.1
At the Colols return I recd a Verbal Answar that the Counsil of safty had no right to give him any Directions—Neither woold he furnish me with one Man or receive any orders from me—That He had Called The Militia together without any order and woold if he pleased Dismiss them the Next Day and requested he might not be troubled with any farther Applications from Genl Forman.
The Militia from that Quarter was Then Comeing in, in Considerable Numbers—it struck me very fully that by persueing any rough Measures towards Genl Newcomb, The Militia might make a pretence of our Dispute to refuse to Assemble & that it was not Improbable to Conclude Genl Newcomb woold even Dismiss Those that ware allready Assembled—I thought it very Imprudent to risque either of these events at that Critical time—on Considering that part of yr Excely Letter of the 31st Wherein your Excly recommends my makeing a Pointed representation of Genl Newcombs Conduct, I Come to the Following resolution Vizt.
The Troops that Marched from Monmouth with me ware previously incorporated with the Garrison in red Bank fort—Those from Burlington I ordered to mudd Island as soon as They should Arrive—Conceiveing I could at no Time be better spared to make The necessary representation in person to The Govr Counsil & Assembly of Genl Newcombs Conduct & at The same time give the Militia Time to Assemble—Genl Varnums being in the Nibourhood allso Conspired to make my presence less Necessary—On Comeing to Trentown I found the Assembly had adjourned to prince Town—To which place I followed them on Monday—The Govr was not then Come.
On Tewsday Evening he Arrive but too Late to do any Business2—Wednessday morning I waited on him Early and fully Explaind Genl Newcombs Conduct3—a Counsil of Safety was Called and a Letter wrote by the Govr with the Advice of The Counsil to Genl Newcomb to give me the Command as being the Eldest officer—and No farther Notice Taken of him.4
While I was here Two Petitions ware handed into The Assembly most unjustly chargeing me and sundry other Gent. with undue practicees on the Day of Election & praying the Election to be set Aside—The Petition Was read in the House and a Hearing ordered on Tewsday Next and a Notice served on me to Attend.5
I immediately went to the Assembly, Informed them of my Then situation and requested the hearing might be Deferrd for a few Days untill the Militia ware Assembled and put in some order—my request was Denyed.
I informed Them that it was impossable for me to do Justice to my Command at red Bank and Attend The House on Tewsday—that I found my self hurt as a Gent. by the Illiberal Charges in the petition—that my reputation as such might suffer should I Neglect to Attend.
On The other hand my reputation as an officer might be injured by my Absence from my post for so long a Time as I Conceived my Attendance in their House woold be Necessary.
That I knew of no way to save my reputation as a Gent. and At the same time to risque nothing as an officer but resigning my Commission—Which I then Delivered to Mr Speaker and Left The House—A few Minutes after I recd a Message From The House Informing that as I had not recd my Commission from Them they Could not receive it and returned it to me. I went Immediately to the Govr from him I recd it and returned it to him.6
Allthough I have Long been Disgusted with The indolance and want of Attention to military Matters in The Legislature of this State I was Determined to Spin out this Campaign in my Slavery, Untill I found a set of Men Ploting by The most unfair Means to stain my reputation.
for I am well perswadeed they ment to take advantage of my Absence & at a Time when they Conceived I woold not have been able to attend—Genl Varnums being at red Bank will I doubt not abundantly Supply my absence.
I have at prest no anxiety but that The step I have taken may not so fully meet your Excely approbation as I could Wish & that I flatter my self I shall have it when I have an opportunity fully to Explain to your Excely my Treatment. I have The Honr to be Your Excelys Most obdt Humble Servt
N.B. I This Minute recd good Information that 36 Sail of Ships Sailed from New York and Sandy Hook on the fifth of This Inst. Supposed to be Genl Clinton.
ALS, DLC:GW. The cover, which indicates that Forman sent this letter “ Express,” is docketed “Ansd,” but that reply has not been found.
1. Elisha Lawrence, Jr. (1746–1799), who was appointed major of the 2d Regiment of Monmouth County militia in October 1775 and was promoted to lieutenant colonel in May 1777, served as a forage master and quartermaster in 1778 and 1779. In the 1780s and 1790s he served intermittently on the New Jersey privy council. As vice-president of the council from 1789 to 1792, Lawrence briefly exercised the duties of governor following William Livingston’s death in 1790. Lawrence is sometimes confused with Loyalist and former Monmouth County sheriff Elisha Lawrence, who served as lieutenant colonel of a battalion of the New Jersey Volunteers.
2. Forman wrote and struck out the word “Morning” before writing the word “Evening.”
3. Forman is referring to Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday, 3, 4, and 5 November.
5. The following Tuesday was 11 November. At issue was the election of representatives for Monmouth County. After the hearing on 11 Nov., the general assembly, by a count of thirteen to twelve, voted on 12 Nov. to void the election (see N.J. Proceedings of the General Assembly description begins Votes and Proceedings of the General Assembly of the State of New-Jersey. At a Session begun at Trenton on the 28th Day of October, 1777, and continued by Adjournments until the 8th of October, 1778. Being their Second Session. Trenton, 1779. description ends , Oct. 1777–Oct. 1778 sess., 7, 16–17).
6. Livingston notified the New Jersey general assembly of Forman’s resignation as brigadier general on 6 Nov. (ibid., 12, and N.J. Proceedings of the Council and General Assembly in Joint-Meeting description begins Minutes and Proceedings of the Council and General Assembly of the State of New-Jersey, in Joint-Meeting, from August 30, 1776, to May, 1780. Trenton, 1780. description ends , 23). Forman retained his commission as colonel of one of the additional regiments in the Continental army, and GW and others continued to refer to him as both colonel and general. An account of Forman’s resignation appeared in the 22 Nov. issue of Rivington’s New-York Loyal Gazette, claiming that he was “removed from his command as a General in the rebel army, in consequence, it is said, of a memorial preferred against him by the inhabitants of Monmouth county, in Jersey, which expressed their abhorrence of his monstrous and deliberate murder of Stephen Edwards of Shrewsbury. . . . The wife of Mr. Furman has, ever since the above atrocious act, been in a state of distraction.”