James Madison Papers

From James Madison to James Monroe, 3 August 1816

To James Monroe

Montpellier Aug. 3. 1816

Dear Sir

I have recd yours of July 31. and return the answer to Mr. B. with one or two alterations, the chief of which is an extension of the arrangement to Lake Champlain. An entire prohibition of armed vessels there where there is much smuggling from Canada, might not be convenient to us; nor would it be reciprocal, considering the manner in which the waters of that Lake are divided between the parties. I see little probability, on the whole of any final agreement, particularly thro’ Mr B. who probably has not & will not receive definitive authority. The best course therefore seems to be, to send some such plan as mentioned in my former letter, to Mr. Adams, with definitive powers to agree to it, or to as much of it as can be attained, and to work a formal arrangement.

The information from Mr. Prentiss,1 may furnish topics for conversation with Mr. Bagot, & communication to Mr Adams. It forbids the hope of any arrangement with the former, if the proposition held out by him be any thing like a measure of his powers.

The name to the other letter now returned, which puzzled you is Sam: L. Mitchill.2 You may express to him the esteem known to be entertained by me, for his learning & talents, and the confidence also entertained in his zeal for patriotic objects, that we are sensible of the merits of those suggested by him, but it does not appear that any distinct provision is authorized for pursuing them in the mode suggested for availing the public, and the cause of science, of the Servic[e]s he tenders. Friendly respects

James Madison

RC (DNA: RG 59, ML). Docketed by John Graham.

1See Benjamin W. Crowninshield’s 25 July 1816 letter to Monroe, which Monroe had forwarded to JM.

2The letter has not been identified, but Monroe appears not to have acted on JM’s suggestion. On 31 Aug. 1816 John Graham reminded Monroe that he had yet to communicate JM’s views to Mitchill, adding that if Monroe did so, “would it not be well to make thro: him some acknowledgments to the Baron L’Escalier for the trouble he took in endeavouring to translate the Letter of Dey of Algiers” (DLC: Monroe Papers).

Index Entries