James Madison Papers

To James Madison from Edmund Randolph, 12 February 1785

From Edmund Randolph

Richmond Feby. 12. 1785.

Dear sir

The inclosed letters were forwarded by the president to my care. Learning from him, that a package, in which they were covered, contained some fresh literary information, I took the liberty of opening it; especially as it was suggested, and the event shewed, that it contained two other letters, one for Mr. Page, the other for Mr. Madison himself.1

The executive are at last persuaded of their power to make the Beccarian experiment on the condemned; altho’ the public should undergo some expense.2 They found their opinion on the law concerning the buildings for the use of the state. An overseer, trusty and diligent, will be therefore appointed, with instructions, fitted to the views of government.

Dr. Price has published a little pamphlet, full of fervor towards America.3 He congratulates himself on having seen the establishment of independence; and marks out some important measures to be pursued, and some ruinous errors to be avoided. Among the former he enumerates the discharge of public debts, especially to the army: to the commander however of which he recommends, that America should always remain indebted—in gratitude. He presses the necessity of extending the powers of congress, perhaps too far even for those among us, who entertain sentiments the most fœderal and of attending to education. Among the latter, he classes ecclesiastical establishments, luxury, the multiplication and unsolemn form of oaths and a mixture with foreign politics, especially for the sake of commerce. Upon the whole the composition displays friendship for mankind, a pen not confined to rigid rules or led by the dicta of others, and indeed shews Price at his political length. I borrowed it for a moment only, and cannot procure a copy for you. I am my dear friend Yrs mo: Sincerely

E. R.

RC (DLC). Cover missing. Not docketed.

1In JM’s answer to Randolph, 10 Mar. 1785, he quoted from Jefferson’s letter of 11 Nov. 1784. The other enclosures were letters from Jefferson, also dated 11 Nov., to the American Philosophical Society president, Francis Hopkinson, and to John Page (Boyd, Papers of Jefferson description begins Julian P. Boyd et al., eds., The Papers of Thomas Jefferson (18 vols. to date; Princeton, N. J., 1950——). description ends , VII, 502, 514–15).

2In a letter to the mayor of Richmond, 13 Jan. 1785, Governor Henry expressed dissatisfaction with the death penalty as disproportionate to crimes committed in certain cases. Since he believed that unconditional pardon was detrimental to society, he preferred the assignment of convicts to public works as an appropriate punishment, and as a deterrent to future offenders (Executive Letter Book description begins Executive Letter Book, 1783–1786, manuscript in Virginia State Library. description ends , pp. 444–45).

3Observations on the Importance of the American Revolution, and the Means of Making it a Benefit to the World (London, 1784). Price’s work was reprinted in a Boston edition of 1784.

Index Entries