Notes on Commentary on the Bible
MS (LC: Madison Papers). With the exception of the extracts from Proverbs, these notes are quoted verbatim, or almost verbatim, from William Burkitt, Expository Notes, with Practical Observations, on the New Testament of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ, first printed posthumously in London in 1724. The pagination of the editorial footnotes is taken from the sixteenth edition of this work, published in London in 1765. Probably this was the edition which Madison’s father received in response to the order of 4 August 1770, which he sent to his Liverpool agents, Clay and Midgeley (MS in Presbyterian Historical Society). Although this is the copy probably used by JM, he may have taken the notes at the College of New Jersey while he was a student there. In view of their structure and the precision with which they mirror Burkitt’s own words, these jottings could hardly have been Madison’s record of what he heard an instructor say. Although undated, the notes closely resemble in their handwriting other Madison manuscripts penned early in the 1770’s.
The four pages of these notes are numbered 4 through 7 consecutively, in an unknown hand, but possibly that of William Cabell Rives. One or more pages, now lost, must have been available to Rives because on pp. 33–34 of the first volume of his Life and Times of James Madison are a few notes by Madison on the New Testament, which are not included in the Library of Congress fragment. Rives’s paragraph and footnote, devoted to these additional comments, are reproduced below, immediately following what JM wrote on the four extant sheets. Although Rives states that the samples he selected for publication reveal JM’s “orthodoxy” and “penetration,” he should rather have remarked that they merely manifested the youthful Madison’s interest in the Bible, perhaps at a time when he felt at least a transient inclination to become a clergyman (JM to Bradford, 25 September 1773, and n. 2).
|Ch. 26.||Hope is the great excitor of Industry and Endeavour||v. 6 &c.|
|Expectation puts it upon Action|
|Power[:] there is a compelling power and constraining Force in Example v. 11.|
|Ministers[:] great is the dignity of Gospel Ministers they are God’s Messengers v. 16. &c.|
|Unconverted has little reason to expect to convert others by their Ministry|
|Ch 27.||St. Paul’s hazardous voyage to Rome, alluded to the Church in her Militant State here on Earth. v. 12. &c. and the danger of spending our youthful days in folly &c.|
|Ch. 28.||Sinful inferrences are drawn from sorrowful premises. v. 4|
|Charity[:] no duty more certainly rewarded in another World; so is it frequently rewarded in this, as was Publius, by the miraculous cure perform’d on his Father for his Charity to Paul. v. 8.|
|Ministers of the Gospel[:] it is the great Duty of them, prudently to prevent, if possible, or presently to remove all Prejudices which may be taken up by their People against their Persons, knowing that, if they have a prejudice against their persons, they will never relish their Doctrine, nor be benefitted by their Ministry. v. 20.2|
|Hope (for the) [sake?] of Israel I am bound: That is; for the Object of Israel’s Hope, or the Messiah which they so long expected, & so much hoped for. v. 20.3|
|Sun, the same that softens the Wax hardens the Clay v. 24 See St. Mark. Ch. 14 V. 66 &c.|
|Gospel stiled the Salvation of God v. 28. & why.|
|Inquisition & Rome, mentioned, at the end.4|
|Mat.5 Ch 1st||Jesus is an Hebrew name and signifies a Saviour v. 1.|
|Christ is a Greek name and signifies Anointed. v. 1|
|Pollution[:] Christ did by the power of his Godhead purify our nature from all the pollution of our Ancestors v. 5. &c|
|Until signifies in Scripture as much as never. v 25|
|Virgin Mary had no other Child (probably) but our Saviour. v. 25|
|Ch. 2||Bethlehem signifies the House of Bread v. 4 &c.|
|Rachel is not here the name of a Person but a place v. 186|
|Ch. 3||Ministers, none to assume the Office before they are sent v. 1.|
|Papists mentioned v 3. & concerning Auricular confession v. 6|
|Hermits lives not supported from the instance of John the Baptist preaching in the Wilderness|
|Sacrament. bad persons upon a profession of Repentance & promise of Amendment may be admitted to the Sacrament. v. 6.7|
|Sins of Omission as Damnable as Sins of Commission v. 10. neglects of Duty as Damnable as Acts of Sin.|
|Grace, where there is most, there is the greatest sense of the want of it. v. 14.|
|Ch. 4.||Adoption[:] Satans grand design is first to tempt the children of God to doubt of it. v. 38|
|Ch. 5.||Christians who allows themselves in the least Transgression, either of omission, or commission is in a Damnable State. v. 19.|
|Ch. 6.||Prayer, a form o[b]served by our Saviour & which ought to be used by us. v. 9.|
|Forgiveness, an indispensable Duty. v. 14|
|Ch. 7.||Gifts, distinguished from Grace. v. 21 &c.|
|Ch. [8.]||Marriage not censured nor condemned in Ministers of the Gospel nor the Apostles v. 14|
|Souls, departed are under the conduct of Angels, good or bad to their places of Bliss or Misery. perhaps at their seperation they are not, immediately fi[xed in?] their eternal Mansions v. 24.|
|Shepherds, or Labourers in Christs Harvest; the idle & lazy, are not so in his Acct. 3[6 &c.]|
|He who doth not instruct his Flock & feed them with the sincere Milk of the Word, from an Heart full of Love to God, & compassion to Souls, deserves not the Name of a true Shepherd|
|Ch. 10.||Apostles, they were Disciples, before they were Apostles. v. 1|
|Grace, the want of it doth not disannul a Ministers Office, nor hinder the Lawfulness of his Ministry. Judas, though a Traitor, was yet a Lawful Minister. V. 4.|
|Lost Sheep, the Israelites so call’d because they were lost in themselves & were in great Danger of being eventually & finally lost, by the Ignorance & Wickedness of their spiritual Guides v. 6.10|
|Preachers, must not be strikers v. 1011|
|Soul, dies not with the Body. 28 V.12|
|Christ’s coming. We must distinguish betwixt his intentional Aim, & the accidental Event of it. v. 3413|
|Reward, There is some special & eminent Reward due to the faithful Prophets of God above other Men. v. 41|
|Ch. 11.||Teaching is in order to the Conversion of Sinners:||v. 1.|
|Preaching in order to the Edification of Saints.|
|Punishment, there are Degrees of it among the Damned. v. 24|
|Ch. 12.||Idle words are such as savour nothing of Wisdom nor Piety v. 38 3614|
|Ch. 13.||Unbelief obstructs Christs gracious works in Heaven. v. 58|
|Ch. 21.||All reformation of manners must begin first at the House of God. v. 13|
|St. Luke, Ch. 2d.—the idle are fit for nothing but Temptation to work on. v. 8 &c.|
|—Such Women whom God has blessed with safety of deliverance should make their first visit to the Temple of God to offer up their Praises & thanksgivings there v. 22d. &c|
|It is said of some Turks that after they have seen Mahomets Tomb, the[y] put out their Eyes, that they may never defile them after they have seen so glorious an object. v. 29.|
|Parts & abilities for the ministerial function are not sufficient to warrant our undertaking of it without a regular Call15|
Some Proverbs of Solomon.16
|Chap. 9.||V. 7. He that reproveth a scorner getteth to himself Shame &c.|
|8. Reprove not a Scorner, lest he hate thee.|
|10.||.17 ———;17 but he that refuseth reproof, erreth|
|26 As Vinegar to the Teeth, and smoke to the Eyes, so is the Sluggard to them that send him.|
|XI.||13. A Tale-bearer revealeth Secrets: but he that is of a faithful Spirit concealeth the Matter 12: v. 2318|
|15. He that is surety for a Stranger shall smart for it: & he that hateth suretyship, is Sure. VI. 1. XVII:1819|
|25. The liberal Soul shall be made Fat &c.|
|XII.||22. Lying Lips are abomination to the Lord: but they that deal truly are his delight.|
|XIII.||12 Hope deferred maketh the Heart Sick &c.|
|24 He that Spareth his Rod hateth his Son: But he that loveth him chasteneth him betimes|
|XIV.||29 He that is Slow to wrath is of great understanding: but he that is hasty of Spirit exalteth folly.|
|XV.||Argumt. Ceremonies to be retained for 3 Reasons from Melancthon20|
|1. A Soft Answer Turneth away wrath: but grievous words stir up anger|
|3 The Eyes of the Lord are in every Place, beholding the evil and the Good.|
|5 A Fool despiseth his Father’s Instruction: but he &c|
|XVI||5. Every one that is pround in heart, is an abomination to the Lord. &c|
|11 A Just weight & balance are the Lord’s: all the weights of the bag are his work|
|16 How much better is it to get Wisdom than Gold: & to get understanding rather to be chosen than Silver|
|24. Pleasant Words are as an Honey-comb, sweet to the Soul & health to the Bones|
|25. There is a way that seemeth right unto a Man, but the end thereof are the ways of Death—XIV. 12.21|
|28. ———; a Whisperer seperateth chief Friends22|
|32. He that is Slow to anger, is better than the Mighty; &c|
|XVIII||8. The Words of a Tale-bearer are as Wounds, & they go down into the innermost parts of the Belly|
|13. He that Answereth a Matter before he heareth it, it is folly & shame unto him.|
|21. Death & Life are in the Power of the Tongue; & they that love it, shall eat the fruit thereof.|
|22 Whoso findeth a Wife findeth a good thing, & obtaineth favour of the Lord.|
|XX||3 ’Tis an honour for a Man to cease from strife: but a fool will be medling;|
|9 Who can say I have made my Heart clean; I am pure from my sin|
|10 Divers weights and measures are abomination to the Lord. v. 2323|
|14 It is naught, it is naught, saith the buyer: but when he is gone his way then he boasteth|
… In24 one of these notes, referring to a chapter of the Acts of the Apostles, where the Bereans are mentioned as “more noble than those in Thessalonica, in that they received the word with all readiness of mind, and searched the Scriptures daily whether these things were so,” he commends their conduct “as a noble example for all succeeding Christians to imitate and follow… .”25
In a paraphrase on the Gospel of St. John, referring to the passage in which Mary Magdalene is represented as looking into the Holy Sepulchre and seeing two angels in white, one sitting at the head and the other at the feet, where the body of the Saviour had lain, he makes the following reflection:
“Angels to be desired at our feet as well as at our head—not an angelical understanding and a diabolical conversation—not all our religion in our brains and tongue, and nothing in our heart and life.”26
In the same spirit, commenting on the chapter of Acts, where Jesus says to St. Paul, who had fallen to the earth under the light which shined round about him from heaven, “Arise, and go into the city, and it shall be told thee what thou shalt do,” he subjoins this as the proper deduction from the passage: “It is not the talking, but the walking and working person that is the true Christian.”27
On doctrinal points, the following brief memoranda28 and references taken from many others of a like character, may serve to show both his orthodoxy and his penetration:
“Omnisciency—God’s foreknowledge doth not compel, but permits to be done.” Acts, ch. II. v. 23.
“Christ’s divinity appears by St. John, ch. XX. v. 28.”
“Resurrection testified and witnessed by the Apostles. Acts, ch. IV. v. 33.”
1. All of these notes on Acts are exactly copied or paraphrased from pp. 363–93 of Burkitt’s volume.
2. By mistake, JM wrote “the” before the first “their” in the paragraph.
3. “Sake” is an editorial guess at the word which JM inadvertently omitted. The antecedent of “they” is “Jews” in verse 19. JM rather than Burkitt supplied the cross-reference to Mark in the next note.
4. By “at the end,” JM meant the close of Burkitt’s commentary on Acts rather than the close of that book of the Bible.
5. JM’s notes on Matthew are all taken from Burkitt’s Expository Notes, pp. 1–57.
6. “Rachel” signified Bethlehem.
7. Baptism is the sacrament referred to here.
8. The “of it” signifies “whether they are children of God [adoption].”
9. Daniel Whitby, A Paraphrase and Commentary on the New Testament (2 vols.; London, 1822), I, 112. These volumes were first published in 1703 and Burkitt, or the editor of his posthumous work, occasionally borrowed comments from them.
10. See Daniel Whitby, Paraphrase and Commentary, I, 114.
11. By “strikers,” Burkitt meant men equipped with “smiting staves” for their own defense.
12. See Daniel Whitby, Paraphrase and Commentary, I, 117.
13. “Event” here means “result,” and the antecedent of “it” is His “coming.”
14. JM first wrote “38”; then, without deleting it, he corrected his error by entering “36” beside it.
15. This is an extract from Burkitt’s comment on verses 46–47.
16. JM, of course, took these extracts from Proverbs rather than from Burkitt’s volume.
17. Since JM frequently left out parts of these verses, he inconsistently indicated omission here of “He is in the way of life that keepeth instruction.” Perhaps he knew this portion by heart.
18. The cross-reference is to the verse: “A prudent man concealeth knowledge; but the heart of fools proclaimeth foolishness.”
19. Each of these verses also deals with suretyship.
20. This line, with its mention of Philipp Melanchthon (1497–1560), a German theologian-reformer who wrote much about church sacraments, is clearly an aside, wholly unrelated to the quotations above or below it.
21. The cross-reference is identical with this verse, except only that “which” is used instead of “that.”
22. The portion omitted reads: “A froward man soweth strife.” See above, n. 17.
23. This is the only instance among these excerpts from the book of Proverbs when JM summed up the sense of the text rather than quoted it exactly.
24. Here, as mentioned above in the headnote, begins the passage printed in William C. Rives, History of the Life and Times of James Madison (3 vols.; Boston, 1859–68), I, 33–34, 34n.
25. William Burkitt, Expository Notes, p. 360, commenting on Acts 17:10–13, but following closely the comment in Daniel Whitby, Paraphrase and Commentary, I, 571.
26. Burkitt, Expository Notes, p. 300, commenting on John 20:12.
27. Burkitt, Expository Notes, p. 335, commenting on Acts 9:6. The “shalt do” is “must do” in the King James version.
28. Burkitt, Expository Notes, pp. 302, 313, 321, following closely the comments in Whitby, Paraphrase and Commentary, I, 489, 512, 519.