Thomas Jefferson Papers

Horatio G. Spafford to Thomas Jefferson, 25 November 1822

From Horatio G. Spafford

Troy, N.Y., 11 Mo. 25, 1822.

Esteemed Friend, Thomas Jefferson:—

After 20 odd years of investigation as an operative Chemist, I have succeeded in demonstrating the truth of a philosophical theory, which enables me to make the very best of Cast-Steel, (a pure carbonate of Iron,) with such facility as to make the manufacture easy & sufficiently profitable. The Steel has been severely tested by the best artisans & mechanics, & is pronounced absolutely superior to the best specimens ever imported. The theory embraces the making of Iron also, & assumes the principle that Iron, pure, is of one quality, uniformly good; that good Iron, sufficiently & equally carbonized, becomes good Steel:—& all this is amply proved by the practise of making, & its results. The system is a broad one, all entirely new, & is secured to me by two Patents. A Company is formed, to go extensively into the manufacture of Steel, men of business, with an ample capital.

Now,—all this I was anxious to let thee know, in gratitude for the kind attentions with which thou hast ever honored me. I also beg leave to say that as the discovery, to be made profitable to me, (and it has cost me a great deal of time, thought & money,) must be kept a secret, I contemplate trying the Congress for a special act of permission to let my specifications remain sealed Papers in the department of State, for the term of 14 years. I am ready to show that body that all I state is reality, proved in practise;—& I pray thee to favor me with thy opinions, whether, having done this, such an Act would be consistent & right, & likely to be granted by the National Legislature?

Or,—were our Government disposed to be wise, & reasonably liberal, I would sell the right for a fair & just sum, to the government, for the benefit of the Country.

In our country, such are the habits of our people that no manufacturing establishment, employing a number of hands, can hope long to keep & enjoy any valuable secret process. Still, with a law to authorise a deposit of my specifications, sealed, for 14 years, in the department of State, I can sell my discovery in the art of making Steel, alone, for an annuity of 5000 dollars per annum, for 14 years.

A little more, (for I trouble thee with as little as possible,) & I then beg leave to ask thy advice. I make Cast Steel, of the best quality, from the Ores of Iron, from Pigs, Bar Iron, &c., all uniformly good, at such a rate as to afford at least 100 per cent clear profit. From Iron Ores of a good quality, I absolutely make it for less than the common selling prices of Bar Iron, made in the old way:—& Iron is made pure & good, for about half the expense of making it, by the usual processes known to artists in the old way. Admitting all this,—& I can prove it all, by persons of high respectability, & by actual experiment, any where, in a few hours, what had I better do with it? I hate lawyers & lawsuits, & I know the cupidity that would rob merit & ingenuity of their reward. My desires as to money are moderate. But nothing will ever tempt me to fail of having the Iron & Steel bear the stamp of my name, let the world call it vanity, or what it will. I wish the Government would stipulate this much, & pay me for the discovery a sum equal to one third of what good judges should say the exclusive right, perfectly secured,1 for 14 years, would be worth, & let the lawyers & lawsuits sleep & die, or be taken care of by the government at its discretion.

Have the goodness to excuse this intrusion on thy retirement, well earned & well merited by a long life devoted to thy Country’s service. Should I go to Washington this winter, as I now propose, it seems to [me] most likely that I shall pay my respects to thee [at] Monticello, if a Kind Providence permit. Heaven grant thee its choicest blessings, thou venerable Father of the Republic, & fill thy evening of life on earth with the consolations of peace, preparatory to a happy immortality in the regions of eternal blessedness. With great regard & affection, thy friend,

Horatio Gates Spafford.

RC (DLC); torn at seal; addressed: “Thomas Jefferson, Monticello, Va.”; stamp canceled; postmarked Troy, 27 Nov.; endorsed by TJ as received 8 Dec. 1822 and so recorded in SJL.

On 30 Oct. 1822 Spafford was awarded two patents for improvements, one in “the art of making cast or wrought steel” and the other in “the art of making iron and steel” (List of Patents description begins A List of Patents granted by the United States from April 10, 1790, to December 31, 1836, 1872 description ends , 243). The specifications are not known to survive. Spafford sent a similar but longer letter to James Madison, also dated 25 Nov. 1822. Madison expressed doubt in his 5 Dec. reply that Congress would grant a special act of permission, and no such law passed at this time. In connection with some subsequent invention, a decade later Spafford did obtain passage of a statute according to which a patent could be issued and kept secret for one year, in the “confidential archives” of the Department of State, for his “alleged discoveries in mechanical philosophy, carried into practical operation by appropriate machinery.” He died shortly thereafter without receiving such a patent (Madison, Papers, Retirement Ser., 2:605–6, 610; U.S. Statutes at Large description begins Richard Peters, ed., The Public Statutes at Large of the United States … 1789 to March 3, 1845, 1845–67, 8 vols. description ends , 6:502 [3 July 1832]; Julian P. Boyd, “Horatio Gates Spafford, Precursor of Bessemer,” APS description begins American Philosophical Society description ends , Proceedings 87 [1943]: 47–50).

1Manuscript: “seecured.”

Index Entries

  • Congress, U.S.; and patents search
  • iron; bar search
  • iron; manufacture of search
  • iron; ore search
  • iron; pig search
  • Madison, James (1751–1836); and H. G. Spafford search
  • patents; of H. G. Spafford search
  • Spafford, Horatio Gates; and iron and steel production search
  • Spafford, Horatio Gates; and J. Madison search
  • Spafford, Horatio Gates; and patents and patent system search
  • Spafford, Horatio Gates; letters from search
  • Spafford, Horatio Gates; wishes to visit TJ search
  • State Department, U.S.; and patents search
  • steel; cast search