From Francis Adrian Van der Kemp
Olden barneveld 8 Sept. 1816.
In answer to your favour of July the 30—I must once more return to the papers, which I Send to England for publication; and am Satisfied with the precautions, I deemed requisite, to conceal the author. Since I received last week information from London of the Sudden desease of mr joÿce—whom I had intrusted with the business I then directly adressed mr. Belsham, Solliciting him to inquire about these papers by the heirs of mr. Joyce, take these under his care—and publish these with the Same precautions, and am fully persuaded, that, although he—from having published in 1812 in Lendsey’s Mem: its chief parts with your Letts to Dr Priestley.1—Can not be mistaken in the author, he Shall not betraÿ his trust. I fully agree with you that a fair and impartial examination of this Subject—on the ground laid by the author must eventually promote truth and establish religion on a basis, which can not be Shaken.
If I am not mistaken in the character of my friends—and I had no hesitation about mr. joyce, there can be no Scruples fostered about its publication in a country, where Basanistes is printed and reprinted—The Liberty of the press is pretty unlimited there—and in it nothing is ridiculed; Here it would be foolishness to try it, as bigotry and intolerance, tho they might not Succeed in persecuting the publication openly, would decry him at least an Atheist, and endeavour to expose him to the insults of a fanatic Rabble. Our young minister has republished here from England a Small tract against the Trinity, Seasoning it, against my entreaties, with Some harsh reflections on one and other of the clergÿ, and Shall, I doubt not gather a harvest of obloquy, as I predicted—It will cool his ardent zeal for truth—and then he Shall become more circumspect, and consequently usefull—I acknowledge however—that forty years ago I Should not have listened much to a doctrine, which I now endeavoured to instil. It is not fear, which makes me reluctant to imitate the hornets—but my peace is at my age too costly a possession to have it disturbed. When thus I intend Something for the Public—I Send it to my friends in England.
I can not blame you, Sir! for waving the answer on Some questions of mÿ Letter—I had no right to ask it, and am not known enough, to be treated with that indulgence. Permit me, however, to observe, that neither a vain curiosity or a Spirit to enter into a controversial correspondence—had the Smallest Share in my inquirÿ—I was lead to it, by what I perused from you, and Seemed to make those answerings desirable. Although I am averse of polemicks, nevertheless, after having perused Some of2 Belsham masterly performances—and bold advances, I was astonished—to find that he maintained yet a Theses—inadmissible in my opinion—with his fundamental Doctrine of the worship of one God—„that J. could work miracles at pleasure„ I have Send him mÿ objections—and urged their discussion—in one of his next publications.
Basanistes is now on a visit to Quincÿ—I Send another work to N. England—from which, with perfect Safety, a Refutation of the doctrine of the Trinity could be copied—being a careful examination of all the passages—brought forward in its defence—and all rejected, peremptorily by one or more learned Trinitarians.
Permit to request the favour of your remembrance, while I assure you that I am with Sentiments of high respect
Fr: Adr. van der Kemp.
RC (DLC); dateline adjacent to closing; endorsed by TJ as received 5 Oct. 1816 and so recorded in SJL. RC (DLC); address cover only; with PoC of first letter from TJ to Joseph Delaplaine of 25 Dec. 1816 on verso; addressed: “Thomas Jefferson LLD. Monticello Virginia”; franked; postmarked Trenton, N.Y., 10 Sept.
TJ was the author of the writings on Jesus’s doctrines. The small tract against the trinity was probably the recently published first American edition of Richard Wright’s pamphlet, An Answer to the Question, Why are you not a Trinitarian? ([Utica, N.Y.], 1816).
Of miracles, Thomas Belsham wrote that Jesus “possessed a voluntary power of working miracles: but his mind was so disciplined by his temptation, and by other circumstances, as to exercise these powers only upon proper occasions” (A Calm Inquiry into the Scripture Doctrine concerning the Person of Christ [London, 1811], 174). In his letter to Van der Kemp of 14 Aug. 1816 (PHi), John Adams (mr. a:) referred to the magnum opus of the English author and layman Abraham Tucker (ODNB description begins H. C. G. Matthew and Brian Harrison, eds., Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, 2004, 60 vols. description ends ).
Van der Kemp advised Adams in a letter dated 7 July 1816 of his plan to publish TJ’s syllabus anonymously in England. He stressed the need for secrecy on TJ’s authorship (MHi: Adams Papers).
1. Section from “from having” to this point interlined.
2. Preceding two words interlined.
- Adams, John; friendship with F. A. Van der Kemp search
- An Answer to the Question, Why are you not a Trinitarian? (R. Wright) search
- Belsham, Thomas; and Jesus’s miracles search
- Belsham, Thomas; and TJ’s syllabus on Jesus’s doctrines search
- Belsham, Thomas; Memoirs of the Late Reverend Theophilus Lindsey, M.A. (T. Lindsey) search
- Christianity; F. A. Van der Kemp on search
- Great Britain; freedom of the press in search
- Jefferson, Thomas; Correspondence; publication of papers search
- Jefferson, Thomas; Opinions on; Jesus search
- Jefferson, Thomas; Writings; syllabus of Jesus’s doctrines search
- Jesus; F. A. Van der Kemp on study of search
- Jesus; miracles of search
- Jesus; TJ on search
- Joyce, Jeremiah; and TJ’s syllabus on Jesus’s doctrines search
- Joyce, Jeremiah; death of search
- Light of Nature Pursued (A. Tucker) search
- Lindsey, Theophilus; Memoirs of the Late Reverend Theophilus Lindsey, M.A. (T. Belsham) search
- Memoirs of the Late Reverend Theophilus Lindsey, M.A. (T. Lindsey; T. Belsham) search
- Priestley, Joseph; TJ’s correspondence with search
- religion; works on search
- Tucker, Abraham; Light of Nature Pursued search
- Van der Kemp, Francis Adrian; and TJ’s syllabus of Jesus’s doctrines search
- Van der Kemp, Francis Adrian; friendship with J. Adams search
- Van der Kemp, Francis Adrian; letters from search
- Van der Kemp, Francis Adrian; on Christianity search
- Van der Kemp, Francis Adrian; proposed work on Jesus search
- Wright, Richard; An Answer to the Question, Why are you not a Trinitarian? search
- Αἱρέσεων ἀνάστασις or, A New Way of Deciding Old Controversies (“Basanistes”) search
- “Basanistes” (pseudonym); Αἱρέσεων ἀνάστασις or, A New Way of Deciding Old Controversies search