From William Duane
Phila Sepr 26, 1813
Dear and respected Sir,
I have the pleasure of receiving yours of the 18th this day—the work of Tracy, is going forward but slowly, as I cannot devote from my present engagements the time I should wish to see it pushed forward. I have put it in the hands of one of Neef’s assistants, a sensible and liberal young man; and Neef is able to render the abstruseness of Tracy’s metaphysis1 a little more comprehensible than my young friend or myself should—I did not calculate upon accomplishing it before the close of the present fall, and I think it will be ready for a full perusal by the end of October.
The affair of the Enterprize & Boxer, has been followed by another triumph still more signal in manner and consequences. The victory on Lake Erie has laid the foundation for the Security of the western countries, which ought to have been long since achieved by the enormous means of every kind money, men, and stores furnished, but which have been wasted in a manner the most shameful and with effects corresponding in disgrace. It is deplorable, with the experience of ages and of our own times, with common sense to resort to, how unfortunate has been the manner in which the military operations were c[omm]enced and the hands in which they were placed. Poor Pike when I last saw him in this city said to me at parting—“I shall go to Canada probably never to return, but I shall go; for the generals we have are all generals of the Cabinet, and it is only after several of us who have some knowlege of military business are Sacrificed, that men will be placed to lead who are now in the ranks or in obscurity—you shall then see our cabinet generals retire and fighting generals brought forward.”
It was a great calamity that such a man as Eustis should have had the appointments of the army at his discretion, since his errors have been a burthen to the country and an obstacle to his successor; that is however now in some measure correcting itself. no man esteems gen Dearborne more than I do, but it was a great mistake to place him in these times at the head of a raw army—and it was still worse to give him coadjutors incompetent from various causes to supply any of his deficiencies. He had Morgan Lewis for Qr master General, who if it could procure him a diadem could not give an instruction nor define the duties of one of his deputies, in fact, it was sending a vessel to Sea without raising her anchors to put such a man in such a station, and yet the expedient resorted to was to make him a Major General who could not execute the duties of Qr master! Another of poor Dearbornes props was Alexander Smythe, a man who to this hour is incapable of exercising a company, and this is the man who was to organize a raw army! General Bloomfield had some experience and was wounded at Brandywine, and his knowlege of details in the old forms is perhaps equal to any one of his cotemporaries; but he has not the remotest idea of modern principles, nor of that distribution of the duties which renders ten thousand men as manageable as one thousand he is a man of [rote?]2—and independent of the effects of a[ge] which is already dotage, he was not competent to any service in action, and especially in Canada; while Pike was in his brigade it was well because Pike saved him the trouble of every sense but hearing—and at last the organization of the Staff, afforded an opportunity to place him where no military service was required, but where it required the greatest patience and a Sentiment of generosity to keep matters out of confusion—a Volunteer association composed of the Sons of Tories and Aristocrats in this city were called into Service by him at the very moment they were defaming the government—they were sent to camp and were a curse to the neighborhood—on their march they entered peacable houses and carried away provisions by violence, tho’ amply supplied by public providence; they practised in common various acts of violence on the public arms in their hands and damed them as Democratic Arms and returned them totally unfit for service; yet these men received public thanks in a General order for their exemplary conduct and discipline! As adjutant General I declined signing and refused to publish such an order—but it is only a Specimen of what was doing on the frontiers
I speak of this matter more fully because it comes under my own Eyes and knowlege—I have no motive of a personal kind to be dissatisfied with Gen. B. and he has more than once said he was fortunate in having me as his adj. Gen. But it goes to shew what unhappy misconceptions governed the choice of officers. Winder was a younger man, but before he was appointed he knew no more of military affairs than his horse; and I am satisfied he could not put a company in motion now after two Years experience. Chandler was not a whit better as to intelligence. The consequences have been Seen, but it has cost the country much treasure and much more precious blood, which might have been saved. But if I were to go into the enumeration of all that might be truly said and deplored on this Subject, you would be tired and I should be ashamed to exhibit a picture so inconsistent with the virtue of a republic and So fatal to its character for talents and public spirit The refusal of Gen. Davie and Governor Ogden of rank in the army, they pretend to justify upon such grounds as those, tho’ I am perfectly aware that their refusal was actuated by different motives. Their nomination however is very characteristic of the fatal policy which has too long prevailed, and which your goodness will excuse me for saying was too much countenancd by yourself; it is too plain that we are not all republicans nor all federalists—and the spirit of faction in the East, I apprehend has been too much encouraged by the mistakes which they perceived we ran into, and which they attributed to a fear of their power instead of that benignity in which it originated
It will be found true I believe in all times that men who are indifferent to social and moral obligations, can be governed by no other means than by their fears or interests; to place men of such a character on a level with men of principle or virtue is to reduce virtu and vice, patriotism and perfidy to a common standard of merit! The effects have been felt in our political affairs—and in our military operations—the army has exhibited a theatre of dissention, and the sword which was sent to the field to assail the Enemy has been too frequently unsheathed to assault the vindicator of his countrys rights and government. The late General Pike told me, that until he witnessed the treasonable and Seditious discourses in the field, he had considered himself a federalist, but that he was not only cured, but astonished how the government ever appointed one of them to a place of honor or confidence. I fear that the policy of courting enemies and sacrificing friends prevails too much in political affairs, and remote and small as its beginnings were, that it has been carried to such a height as if not speedily put a stop to by some generous and magnanimous rallying of the republicans, it will end in the frustration of all the good that has arisen out of the triumph of 1800. I could Say a great deal on this topic if I were not afraid of tiring you or giving you pain—and I have not written on politics so much as I have now written since March last.
The sentiments you express concerning the unhappy men in the hands of the enemy, have warmed my most affectionate feelings towards you—Would to God that Mr Madison felt as you do, and would act upon it; he would glorify himself and it would do more than ten sail of the line or twenty thousand men in prosecuting the war to a peace, and in elevating our country in the eyes of the World. Can it be possible that Mr Madison does not converse with you or is his health such as to render him unable; surely Mr Monroe would think and act with your thoughts. It would be rendering a most honorable Service to Mr Madison and to humanity to point out this glorious path to Justice and national Dignity
I have never had the confidence or personal knowlege of Mr Madison with which you have honored me, or I should have written him on such subjects often. A man has been lately Sent from Halifax to England in Irons who has been a citizen of the U.S. 20 years and with a family!
You may expect very soon to hear of something very decisive and brilliant by our land forces—the orders for operations have been issued for movements at four points on the same day; the Erie business will favor Harrisons operations, if he has only prudence to consult some man of talents as to his operations; but Proctor must evacuate Michigan and Malden to prevent being cut off; if Harrison possessed3 either talents or enterprize he would by throwing 2000 men across the Lake to Long Point, compel him to Surrender at Discretion.
The operations going on4 lately have had in view to deceive the enemy, and it has succeeded admirably for I find Sir Geo. Prevost has forsaken Kingston, where he ought to have made his stand in order to go up to the head of the Lake, to meet those demonstrations which were making there for no purpose in the world, as I believe but to delude him into a snare.
The division under Gen. Hampton has proceeded down Champlain; the troops with him are select and excellent; he has some able men near him, and he has discretion enough to depend on them more than on himself, which is no bad quality in such a responsible station—being in it. I presume that he will be, (as he ought to be) in montreal at least before the 1st of October; in that event our whole force must be brought below. Kingston will I suppose be taken by Wilkinson. Quebec will be left for the end of may & June next—when it must fall—a siege of four weeks ought to bring Quebec under the American banner.
But I have tired you—if it is not interesting it will be at least an evidence of my unabated respect and confidence in Your continued liberality & friendship
RC (DLC); hole in manuscript; endorsed by TJ as received 6 Oct. 1813 and so recorded in SJL.
The work of Destutt de tracy was the manuscript of the fourth volume of his Élémens d’Idéologie. The sensible and liberal young man was William T. Woodman, who wrote Duane on 23 Dec. 1813 from Falls of Schuylkill, Pennsylvania, that “When I commenced the translation of the manuscript you sent me, it was my intention, after having once gone over it, to transcribe the whole of it, and correct the language, which I am conscious is far from being as pure and perspicuous as it ought to be. But situated as I was, so much of my attention was engrossed by the school, that I had very little time to devote to the translation, in consequence of which it was so long on hand that I have been unable to accomplish my original design. I am fearful my present indispensable engagements, will for a considerable length of time prevent me from giving it the necessary corrections. As I send it to you it is almost a literal version from the original, and for this reason it abounds with Gallicisms, and awkward constructions. You will of course make every alteration and amendment that you may think proper, and if you find it too inaccurate to be corrected, as it comes from the press, I will endeavour to find time to amend it as soon as possible” (RC in ViU: TJP; addressed: “Col. Wm Duane No 98. Market Street Philadelphia”).
The American naval commander Oliver Hazard Perry had scored an important victory on lake erie on 10 Sept. 1813 (Heidler and Heidler, War of 1812 description begins David S. Heidler and Jeanne T. Heidler, eds., Encyclopedia of the War of 1812, 1997 description ends , 413). TJ famously declared in his first inaugural address that “We are all republicans: we are all federalists” (PTJ description begins Julian P. Boyd, Charles T. Cullen, John Catanzariti, Barbara B. Oberg, and others, eds., The Papers of Thomas Jefferson, 1950– , 34 vols. description ends , 33:149). long point is on Lake Erie. kingston is on Lake Ontario.
1. Thus in manuscript, a rarely used word meaning “transformation, metamorphosis” (OED description begins James A. H. Murray, J. A. Simpson, E. S. C. Weiner, and others, eds., The Oxford English Dictionary, 2d ed., 1989, 20 vols. description ends ). Duane may have intended “metaphysics.”
2. Word illegible.
3. Manuscript: “possed.”
4. Manuscript: “only.”
- Bloomfield, Joseph; military experience of search
- Boxer, HMS (brig) search
- Canada; U.S. invasion of search
- Chandler, John (1762–1841); military career of search
- Davie, William Richardson; refuses military appointment search
- Dearborn, Henry; W. Duane on search
- Destutt de Tracy, Antoine Louis Claude; Élémens d’Idéologie search
- Duane, William; and Destutt de Tracy’s works search
- Duane, William; letters from search
- Duane, William; on H. Dearborn search
- Duane, William; on W. Eustis search
- Duane, William; on War of1812 search
- Élémens d’Idéologie (Destutt de Tracy) search
- Enterprise, USS (brig) search
- Eustis, William; W. Duane on search
- Hampton, Wade; War of1812service of search
- Harrison, William Henry; War of1812service of search
- Jefferson, Thomas; Writings; First Inaugural Address search
- Lewis, Morgan search
- Madison, James; administration of search
- Monroe, James; as secretary of state search
- Neef, Joseph; and translation of Destutt de Tracy manuscript search
- Ogden, Aaron; refuses military appointment search
- Pike, Zebulon Montgomery; and War of1812 search
- Prevost, George; governor-in-chief of British North America search
- Procter, Henry; British military commander search
- Smyth, Alexander; and Niagara Campaign search
- War of1812; Niagara Campaign search
- War of1812; O. H. Perry’s victory on Lake Erie search
- War of1812; W. Duane on search
- Wilkinson, James; War of1812service of search
- Winder, William Henry; military experience of search
- Woodman, William T.; translates Destutt de Tracy manuscript search