From Arthur Campbell
Richmond Nov. 29. 1782
On my way here I shewed Colo. Preston the tooth I sent you. At first sight, before I told him where it was found, he give it as his opinion that it was of the same animal as those found near the Ohio, a tooth of which he had obtained above 30 years ago and thinks it was sent to England. Doctor Lee says it is the same species, of that sent to England from the Ohio, that being a member, he was present when the subject was discussed, in a meeting of the Royal Society, and that it was satisfactorily demonstrated, that the species was of the carnivorous kind. Perhaps the result of this produced Doctr. Hunters Publication. Several sensible Africans have seen the tooth, particularly a fellow at your neighbour Colo. Lewises, all of whom pronounced it an Elephants. A certain Mr. Stanley was captivated by the Indians, some years ago, near the mouth of the Cherokee River on his way to the Mississippi. I have been told by different persons that since his return, he relates, that after being transfered from one Tribe to another, he was at length carried over Mountains west of the Missouri, to a River that runs Westwardly; that the natives told him there were animals in the Country which from the description he judges to be Elephants. These apparent contradictions still leaves the matter in doubt. I trouble you with the information to assist in your researches.
I hear you are destined for Europe, and am particularly happy you are likely to have a share in forming the ultimatum of our long Struggle. The Western Country I have been afraid, would not be properly attended to. I who have travelled thro it, in different directions from Lake Huron, to the Hiwasee, well know its importance: It will cramp our prospects exceedingly, and be ruinous to the adjacent Country, should Britain retain her Claim to the banks of the Ohio. We had better fight a year or two more than submit to such a Claim. I am told that it was once the view of Congress to insist for our limits, to extend as high as Lat. 45°. I should think we have gained a great point if it would include the Cataract at Niagara, west thro the middle of Lake Erie to the Illinois and down the same. Excuse my freedom. My prayers and best wishes will attend you. With sentiments of the most perfect esteem and respect I am Sir Your most Obedient Servant,
P.S. I will not fail in sending other Bones to Mr. Steptoe.
RC (DLC); addressed: “The Honbe. Thomas Jefferson.”
Doctor Lee: Arthur Lee, who had earned his M.D. at Edinburgh, afterwards settled in London and in 1766 was elected a member of The Royal Society, at a meeting of which (25 Feb. 1768) the famous anatomist doctr. [William] hunter read a paper on the collection of fossil bones furnished by George Croghan and housed in the Tower of London. In this paper, entitled “Observations on the Bones, Commonly Supposed to Be Elephant’s Bones, Which Have Been Found Near the River Ohio, in America” (Philos. Trans. Royal Soc., lviii , 34–45), Hunter concluded that the bones were those of a carnivorous mammal, not the elephant, which he designated as the “American incognitum” and which he believed was extinct. In Notes on Virginia, Query vi, TJ agreed with Hunter that the fossil bones found in the Ohio Valley were those of a carnivore and not the elephant, but he denied that the incognitum or American mammoth was extinct, citing Indian testimony and also the Mr. Stanley mentioned in the present letter in support of this view (Ford, description begins Paul Leicester Ford, ed.,The Writings of Thomas Jefferson,“Letterpress Edition,” N.Y., 1892–1899 description ends iii, 130ff., 144). On the controversy over the fossil bones, see George Gaylord Simpson, “The Beginnings of Vertebrate Paleontology in North America,” Amer. Philos. Soc., Procs., lxxxvi (1942–1943), 148ff. A MS copy of Hunter’s paper is to be found among the papers of Thomas Hutchins, PHi.