From Ralph Izard
ALS: American Philosophical Society; copy and two transcripts: National Archives; transcript: South Carolina Historical Society
Paris 25th: April 1778.
It is with the utmost astonishment that I find myself so often obliged to remind you of your engagement to me. You have repeatedly given me the strongest assurances that you would justify your conduct to me in writing, but you have not kept your word. Dr. Bancroft, and your Grandson have both told me that this justification has long ago been begun, and that you have several times been employed about it.2 The cautious manner in which you concealed the departure of Mr. Gerard the French Plenipotentiary, and of Mr. Deane, from those who have complaints against you, manifest on your part no inclination to discontinue the causes of them. The losses of the public dispatches to Congress by accidents at Sea, by the capture of the enemy, and by the villainy, or negligence of those to whose care they have been intrusted, ought to have deterred you from concealing so safe an opportunity from those, whose duty requires them to write. It might have been very proper that the Port from which they were to sail should have been concealed, as well as the manner of their going; but it appears to me to be your indispensable duty to inform those Gentlemen who have the honour of holding Commissions from Congress, whenever you know of a safe opportunity of writing to America. It may not be necessary to discuss this point with you, as it will probably be laid before Congress; and they will form a proper judgement, both of the fact, and of your motives. My business with you at present respects your conduct previous to the departure of Mr. Gerard, and Mr. Deane; and I wish that neither your attention nor mine may be drawn from it. Mr. Lloyd3 has informed me that you told him there would be an opportunity of writing soon to America. I must request that you will no longer attempt to amuse me with promises, and excuses, but that you will give me the explanation which you have so often bound yourself to give, that it may be laid by that opportunity, if necessary, before the Representatives of my Country; or that you will let me know in writing that you will not give it me. I am Sir Your Most Obedient humble Servant
The Honourable Benjn. Franklin Esqr.
2. Promised in BF’s letter above, April 4. The only explanation Izard ever obtained seems to have been oral, through his secretary, who interviewed BF the next day and delivered this letter: Pringle to Izard below, April 26.
3. Not John, the merchant in Nantes, but Richard Bennett Lloyd of Maryland. He was educated in England, became a captain in the Coldstream Guards, and resigned his commission on the outbreak of war: Md. Hist. Mag., XLIV (1949), 6 n. Although he was a friend of Izard, he subsequently had some contact with BF. He had more with Adams, who was often in his company but told little about him except that he had a handsome English wife: Butterfield, John Adams Diary, IV, 67 and passim (the index misnames him as John Lloyd). At the end of the year he and his wife went to England, and he kept in touch with BF by letter.