Benjamin Franklin Papers

To Benjamin Franklin from Courtney Melmoth, 28 January 1778

From Courtney Melmoth

ALS: American Philosophical Society

Rue Jacob, Paris 28. i5 1778


Were it likely to suppose that the human mind, however comprehensive, could always be exerted on one Subject, even tho that subject be the fate of Empires, I should never attempt to seduce your attention to any trifle that could possibly drop from either my own Pen, or that of any part of my family; but, when I consider that the profoundest sagacity must often seek refuge in really unimportant Relaxations, I am encourag’d to send, for the Hours of your Leizure, a copy of the last Publication which I have ventured to send into the World. It is accompanied by a little Poem which, tho written in my Hand, is, with very little alteration, the effort of Mrs. Melmoth’s Thoughts, upon a Subject that I hope you will find not unacceptable. I had, in correcting the original, made some defaceing Interlineations, for which reason she insisted on my makeing a fair transcription. With regard to the Travels, I must warn you of many horrid blunders which hath been occasioned by my absense from the Press. Conscious that an Eye so penetrating as Doctor Franklin’s will detect many Errours that are absolutely in the writing and not in the printing, it is a mere justice I owe myself, to mask such as do not belong to me.6 I am Sir Your most obedient Servant

Courtney Melmoth


To Doctor Franklin

For the Author who was present when he gave his Portrait to a Lady


The wrong’d have Reason to complain;

I prove it by the Laws of Pain;

And slighted Women play the duce

When they but fancy an abuse.

This Stanza serves by way of Text,

The Cause of Quarrel in my next.

Know I am deeply injured, Sir,

And thus I prove what I aver.

Did you not, late, in open day,

Full liberal, give yourself away?

Did not the happy Laura bear the Prize?7

Did not the Insult pass before my Eyes?

I guess, good Sir, the Plea you’l use,

But tis too feeble for Excuse;

You’l say, the Lady is more fair

Or breathes, perhaps, your native Air;

You’l say you long have known her Merit,

Her Sense, her Elegance, or Spirit:

All this admitted, was it just

That she alone should have a Bust,

Even while its counterpart was by

And leave this Jealous Breast—a Sigh?

Or did you think, because the Earth

Of wayward England gave me birth,

I had not Soul to pass the Line,

And honour Worth and Wit like thine?

Believe me Sir, tho briton-born,

Tyrants I hate, and Slaves I scorn,

And if your Portrait I desire’d

It was because fair Freedom fire’d

It was—but hence all altercation,

You know my terms of—Reconciliation.

Notation: Mr Melmoths Letters & Papers

[Note numbering follows the Franklin Papers source.]

5The digit is virtually illegible, but the month has to be January because the Melmoths moved from the Rue Jacob before Feb. 28.

6The book was Travels for the Heart . . . (2 vols., London, 1777), written in France in imitation of Sterne’s Sentimental Journey.

7Mrs. Izard; see BF’s reply that follows.

Index Entries