To Major General Robert Howe
Head Quarters West-point 7th Sepr 1779.
I have to acknowlege your two favors of the 5th inst. one public the other marked private.1
The current of my intelligence by different hands and from different quarters bring the enemy’s reinforcement to about 3,000.2 This corresponds with your accounts3—and perhaps is pretty near the truth.
The ignorance of the agents of [ ] or the want of a proper genius for enquiry or observation may have led them to over rate their numbers. Caution however as you observe is necessary on our part. We will seem pleased with their every accounts—but believe only such of them as appears to be supported by the greatest variety of evidence. As Mr —— has been written for he may set out for Philada when he thinks proper.
While I am writing—I have received your favor of the 6th.4 Your precautions appear to me to have been well taken for the security of your post—& I am sensible of the extent of protection which it gives to a country—that would otherwise be exposed to the inroads of the enemy—The move more to the right was thought of5 under the uncerty of the E[nem]ys Stre. and on the supposition of their reinforcement being considerable, and the propriety of having the whole army in a condition to operate at the shortest notice & to the greatest advantage.6 But As their reinforcement seems to be below what was apprehended the proposed change of your position does not therefore appear necessary at present.7 I am my dear sir your &c.
P.S. I have just recd a letter from Genl Sullivan of the 30th Augt. he informs me that the collected Force of Indians and Tories under the command of the two Butlers, Brant and McDonald met him at a place called the New town upon the Cayuga River. They were very advantageously posted and intrenched. Genl Sullivan forced their works, from which they fled with precipitation, leaving 11 Warriors dead and evident marks of a much greater loss—they also left behind a number of Arms their packs, Blankets, Camp Kettles and such Baggage as such an Army might be supposed to have. our loss 3 Killed. 39 Wounded. He destroyed their Crops at this place, which were very extensive. Be pleased to forward the inclosed to Majr Talmadge immediately.8
Df, in James McHenry’s and Tench Tilghman’s writing, DLC:GW; Varick transcript, DLC:GW. Tilghman wrote the postscript. GW made an addition to the draft, as noted below.
1. These letters have not been found.
2. GW is referring to the 3,800 British army reinforcements that had arrived at New York on 25 Aug. (see GW to John Jay, 24–27 Aug., and n.8 to that document). For the full scope of GW’s defensive preparations for the arrival of this reinforcement, see GW to Jay, 11 Aug., n.5.
3. McHenry, who penned the body of the draft, wrote the words “in general” above the last three words, but he did not mark a location for their insertion in the text.
4. This letter has not been found.
5. The next eight words are in GW’s writing.
7. At this point on the draft, the following text is struck out: “You will therefore continue on your ground.”
8. This enclosure was most likely GW’s letter to Maj. Benjamin Tallmadge of this date.