Deposition of John Gibson
Allegeney County ss. State Pensa.
Before me the Subscriber a justice of the Peace in and for said County, personally appeared John Gibson Esqr. an associate Judge of same County, who Being duly sworn deposeth and Saith that he traded with the Shawanese and other tribes of Indians then setled on the Siota in the year 1773, and in the Beginning of the year 1774, and that in the Month of April of the same year, he left the same Indian towns, and came to this place, in order to procure some goods, and provisions, that he remained here only a few days, and then set out in Company with a Certain Alexd. Blaine and Mat.1 Elliot by water to return to the towns on Siota, and that one Evening as they were drifting in their Cannoes near to the Long Reach on the Ohio, they were hailed by a number of White Men on the South West Shore, who requested them to put a Shore as they had disagreeable News to Inform them of, that we then Landed on Shore and found amongst the party, a Major Angus Mac. Donald from Winchester, a Doctor Woods from same Place, and a party as they said of 150 Men, we then asked the News, they informed us that some of the Party who had Been taken up, and Improving Lands near the Big Konhawa river, had seen another party of white Men, who informed them that they and some others had fell in with a party of Shawnese who had Been hunting on the South west side of the Ohio, that they had Killed the whole of the Indian party and that the others had gone across the Country to Cheat River with the horses and plunder, the Consequence of which they Apprehended would be an Indian War, and that they were flying away. On Making Enquiry of them when this murder shoud have happened, we found that it must have Been some considerable time Before we left the Indian towns, and that there was not the Smallest foundation for the Report, as there was not a Single Man of the Shawnese, But what returned from Hunting long Before this shoud have happened.
We then informed them that if they woud agree to remain at the place we then were, one of us woud goe to Hock Hockung river with some of their party, where we shoud find some of our People making Cannoes, and that if we did not find them there, we might Conclude that every thing was not right, Doctor Wood and another person then proposed going with me, the rest of the party seemed to agree, But said they woud send and Consult Capt. Cressap who was about two Miles from that Place, they sent of for him, and during the grea[…] part of the Night they Behaved in the Most disorderly Manner threatning to Kill us, and Saying the damned traders were worse than the Indians and ought to be Killed. In the Morning Capt. Michael Cressap came to the Camp, I then gave him the Informat[ion] as above related, they then met in Council, and after an hour or more Capt. Cressap, returned to me and informed that he coud [not] prevail on them to adopt the proposal I had made to them, that as he had a great regard for Capt. R. Callender a Brother in Law of Mine with whom I was connected in trade, he advised me by no means to think of Proceeding any further, as he was convinced the present party woud fall on and Kill every Indian they met [on the] River; that for his part he shoud not Continue with them, But go right across the Country to Red Stone to avoid the Consequences—that we the2 proceeded to Hockung and went up the same to the Cannoe Place where we found our people at Work and after some days we proceeded to the towns on Siota by Land on our arrival there, we heard of the dift3 Murders committed by the Party on their way up the Ohio.
This Deponent further saith that in the Year 1774, he accompanied Lord Dunmore on the Expedition against the Shawnese and other Indians on the Siota, that on their Arrival within 15 Miles of the towns, they were met by a Flag, and a White Man of the name of Elliot, who informed Lord Dunmore, that they Chiefs of the Shawnese had sent to Request his Lordship to halt his army and send in some person, who understood their Language, that this Deponent at the Request of Lord Dunmore and the whole of the Officers with him went in, that on his arrival at the towns, Logan the Indian came to where this deponent was Sitting with the Corn Stalk and the other Chiefs of the Shawnese, and asked him to walk out with him, that they went into a Copse of Woods, where they Sat down, when Logan after shedding abundance of tears, delivered to him the Speech, nearly as related by Mr. Jefferson in his notes on the State of Virga., that he this Deponent told him then that it was not Col. Cressap who had Murdered his Relations, and that altho his Son Capt. Michl. Cressap was with the party who killed a Shawnese Chief and other Indians,4 yet he was not present when his Relations were killed at Bakers5 near the Mouth of Yellow Creek on the Ohio. that this Deponent on his Return to Camp delivered the Speech to Lord Dunmore; and that the Murders perpetrated as above was considered as Ultimately the Cause of the War of 1774, commonly Called Cressaps war—
Sworn and Subscribed this 4th. of April 1800. at Pittsburg at Pittsburg
MS (DLC: TJ Papers, 104:17915, 106:18237); in Gibson’s hand, signed by him and Barker; frayed; with TJ’s numerals in margin to identify instances of violence against Native Americans in 1774 according to his key in the Appendix to the Notes on Virginia (see notes below; Notes, ed. Peden description begins Thomas Jefferson, Notes on the State of Virginia, ed. William Peden, Chapel Hill, 1955 description ends , 231; Vol. 30:102n). Printed in An Appendix to the Notes on Virginia Relative to the Murder of Logan’s Family (Philadelphia, 1800); with minor variations of punctuation, capitalization, and spelling (Notes, ed. Peden description begins Thomas Jefferson, Notes on the State of Virginia, ed. William Peden, Chapel Hill, 1955 description ends , 232–4).
A letter from Gibson to TJ, dated 21 Mch. 1800 and received on 3 Apr., and one from TJ to Gibson of 16 Apr. are recorded in SJL but have not been found. Gibson incorporated a portion of his letter to TJ of 17 June 1797 into the final paragraph of the deposition above; see Gibson to TJ, 14 Mch. 1800.
In the Appendix the deposition printed above was followed by a letter, dated 4 Feb. 1800 at Wheeling, from Ebenezer Zane to Senator John Brown of Kentucky. Brown probably gave the letter to TJ, who made no markings on it but retained it in his papers. Zane reported his knowledge of two incidents in April 1774 in which armed groups led by Michael Cresap killed Indians. He also stated that although Cresap was not involved in the murder of Logan’s relatives at Yellow Creek, his actions precipitated both that incident and Dunmore’s War. The Appendix omitted the first paragraph of the letter, in which Zane indicated that he was responding to an inquiry from Brown dated 23 Jan. As published, the letter contained the numerals 1, 2, and 3 inserted in brackets to locate the incidents mentioned by Zane within the sequence of events that TJ identified in the Appendix (RC in DLC, addressed to Brown at Philadelphia and franked, printed in the Appendix with minor variations; Notes, ed. Peden description begins Thomas Jefferson, Notes on the State of Virginia, ed. William Peden, Chapel Hill, 1955 description ends , 235–6). Zane (1747–1812) had been born on the Virginia frontier. He laid out the town of Wheeling and was active in land speculation and development in what became the state of Ohio (ANB description begins John A. Garraty and Mark C. Carnes, eds., American National Biography, New York and Oxford, 1999, 24 vols. description ends ).
1. Because Gibson did not always cross the letter “t,” this could be mistaken for “Mal.” That confusion probably accounts for the compression to “M.” in the Appendix to the Notes on Virginia, where Blaine’s first name and Michael Cresap’s in the deposition’s last paragraph were expanded rather than contracted.
2. Appendix: “then.”
3. Appendix: “different.”
4. Notation by TJ in margin: “2.”
5. Notation by TJ in margin: “3.”