From Major Thomas Cogswell
To His Excellency General Washington, Commander in Chief of the Army of the United States of America—
The Humble Petition of Thomas Cogswell Major in the Massachusetts Line, Sheweth.
That in settling the Rank of the Feild Officers of the Fifteen Battalions from said State, at Valley Forge Your Petioner was (as he thinks) much injured, in not having justice done him as to his Rank, in a number of instances, He mentions only one instance, which will be Sufficient to convince your Excellency that there was not that attention paid to your Petioner which in justice ought to have been—Major Porter was rank’d before your Petioner although he was not a Captain till several months after him—& your Petioner receiv’d a Majors Commission the first of January 1777 Major Porter did not receive his Commission till the 14th of June following, and there was no Vacancy till after the 20th of may—Your Petioner has been in the Service ever since the Commencement of the War, & Major Porter was not in the Line in 1776—Your Petioner was absent on Command at the time the Rank was settled at Valley Forge, & did not join the Army till a few days before the Battle at Monmouth which being an improper time to trouble your Excellency with matters of that kind, he thought proper to wave it—& has had no opportunity Since by reason of movements of the Brigade—With this I shall present my pretensions to Rank,1 & rest assured that your Excellency will rank me in such place as my long Services Deserve & my Pretensions entitle me to—and Your Petioner as in Duty bound will ever pray.
Thomas Cogswell Major
of the Massts Regt Commd by Col. Vose
ALS, DNA: RG 93, manuscript file no. 2097.
1. On a separate sheet also dated 24 July, there is a statement signed with Cogswell’s name, although it appears to have been authored by another person. It reads: “Major Cogswells Pretensions to rank Was appointed Captain of a Company of Militia in 1774—On the 15th of April 1775 Marched with one hundred Volunters under my Command to oppose the Enemy at Lexington, & soon after entered the Service as a Captain & continued as such till December 1776—Commissiond as a Major January 1777—& drew pay & Rations accordingly” (DNA: RG 93, manuscript file no. 2097).
Col. William Shepard, Col. Timothy Bigelow, Col. Joseph Vose, Lt. Col. Commandant Ebenezer Sproat, and Lt. Col. Elijah Vose also wrote GW on this date to recommend “as a Deserving & Good Officer Major Cogswell of Colo. Voses Regt He having ever conducted in the Service, as far as we have seen as became the Character of the Officer & the Gentleman, & we would wish that he might have that rank which his long Services & Pretensions entitle him to” (LS, DNA: RG 93, manuscript file no. 2097). GW’s secretary Robert Hanson Harrison wrote on the undated docket of this letter that Cogswell’s pretensions were “determined against him.”