To William Livingston
Head quarters. Morris Town. Febry 11th 1777
I have with pain heard of the irreconcileable Uneasinesses prevailing in the 1st N. Jersey Battalion, originating, as I am credibly informed, in the appointment of Colo. Newcomb to the Command of it.
Notwithstanding I believe that Colo. Newcomb is a Gentleman of great Goodness and Integrity, and can not entertain the slightest doubts of his Bravery, yet I am too well persuaded that he is not equal to such a Command. Many qualities, independent of personal Courage, are requisite to form the good Officer. Among these, Activity claims a first rank; indeed it is indispensably necessary—Of this, I fear, he does not possess a sufficient Share. Moreover the inferior Officers of every Regiment should have the strictest Confidence in their Colonel—The smallest Jarrings in any Corps are considerably prejudicial to its Honour and the Service.
For these reasons, and these only, I have taken the Liberty (under the Authority of the inclosed Resolve of Congress) to displace Colo. Newcomb, and of appointing Colo. Mathias Ogden to the command of the said Regiment. He has answered my Expectation by exerting himself in recruiting the Regimt, and from every thing I can learn will continue to deserve well of his Country.1
I would not take the Liberty of intruding upon your more important business now, were it not necessary to give You this Information, least Inconveniences might result from your belief that Colo. Newcomb continues to fill the Post which You have assigned to him. Colo. Ogden has likewise my Commands to fill up the several Vacancies that have happened in the Regimt; subject however to my Approbation or Dissent. These Officers are now recruiting. I have the Honour to be, with the greatest Respect and Esteem, Yr most Obedient Humble Servant
LS, in George Johnston’s writing, MHi: Livingston Papers; Df, DLC:GW; Varick transcript, DLC:GW.
1. GW apparently enclosed a copy of Congress’s resolution of 27 Dec. 1776 giving GW the power “to displace and appoint all officers under the rank of brigadier general” (JCC description begins Worthington Chauncey Ford et al., eds. Journals of the Continental Congress, 1774-1789. 34 vols. Washington, D.C., 1904–37. description ends , 6:1045). The New Jersey general assembly appointed Silas Newcomb brigadier general of the militia on 15 Mar. 1777, and he subsequently ran afoul of GW later in the year when called upon to assist in the defense of the Delaware River (see GW to Livingston, 1 Nov. 1777, LS, MHi: Livingston Papers).