Thomas Jefferson Papers
Documents filtered by: Recipient="Jefferson, Thomas"
sorted by: author
Permanent link for this document:
https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Jefferson/01-42-02-0210

Petition of Joseph Goodier, with Jefferson’s Order, 4 January 1804

Petition of Joseph Goodier,
with Jefferson’s Order

To Thomas Jefferson President
of the United States

The petition of Joseph Goodier humbly and respectfully sheweth—That on the 3rd. instant he was convicted in the Circuit Court of the District of Columbia for Washington County of stealing a Steer the property of Daniel Carroll of Dudington and has been sentenced by the said Court to pay1 a fine of one dollar, with the costs of prosecution and to be publickly whipped with five lashes. The circumstances under which he was convicted were so favourable that the Jury were induced to recommend him to the mercy of the Court—but the law positively requiring it the Court was under a necessity of making whipping a part of his punishment Being a young man dependant for his living on his industry and reputation in society the latter of which must inevitably suffer almost irretrievably by a public and ignominious punishment He humbly prays that the President will be pleased to pardon his Offence or at least to remit that part of his sentence which inflicts Whipping and he will ever pray &c

Joseph Goodier
City of Washington
4 January 1803 [i.e. 1804]

The Jury recommended the petitioner to the Mercy of the Court, on which they ordered as slight a punishment as they could, not having the power to dispense with that part of the Law which inflicts corporal punishment; but they are willing and do respectfully recommend to the President to remit the said corporal punishment

W Kilty

W. Cranch

N. Fitzhugh

[Order by TJ:]

A pardon to be issued as to the corporal punishment.

Th: Jefferson

Jan. 7. 1804.

MS (DNA: RG 59, GPR); misdated; recommendation of the court in a clerk’s hand and signed by Kilty, Cranch, and Fitzhugh. Enclosed in Daniel Carroll Brent to TJ, 6 Jan. 1804, forwarding “papers respecting a certain Goodier now in Jail, which I am directed by the court to transmit to you” (RC in DLC; misdated 1803; endorsed by TJ as a letter of 6 Jan. 1804 received that day and “Joseph Goodier’s case” and so recorded in SJL).

TJ issued a pardon of Goodier’s corporal punishment on 7 Jan. (FC in Lb in DNA: RG 59, GPR).

1Word interlined in place of “be punished by.”

Index Entries