John Jay Papers
Documents filtered by: Author="Gates, Horatio"
sorted by: recipient
Permanent link for this document:
https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Jay/01-01-02-0364

To John Jay from Horatio Gates, 15 March 1779

From Horatio Gates

Boston March 15th. 1779.

Sir,

Persuaded that your Excellency punctually attends to every Thing which may respect the Eastern Department, as you declared in the first Letter I have been honoured with from you, since you are in the Chair; I hope all my Letters, since my Arrival in Boston, will be answered as far as it may be necessary for my Conduct.

I do not yet know what Congress intend to do towards fortifying this City and Harbour, the Necessity of which I urged in my Letter of the 30th: of November last, inclosing General Duportail’s Memorial on that Subject.— The Season advances rapidly and we may be attacked before we have Troops, a Magazine to feed them, or proper Batteries to keep off the Enemy.— What the British Generals will attempt, I know not; but the Advantages we throw in their Laps are really alarming to us.— The Invitation which the State of this City now presents to them is so tempting, that I believe, if they were ordered to return to Europe, they would visit us here, before their Departure, even tho’ they had no other Prospect than that of exalting their own military Fame, and diminishing the Opinion which our Friends entertain of our Wisdom.—1

The most opulent Families of this City are without Bread, and the Poor almost in a State of Desperation.— The public Magazine being guarded by, and consequently at the Mercy of the Militia of this State, I fear with more Reason than it is prudent to publish, that Violence will take away the few Barrels of Flower which are left.— It cannot be expected that the People of New England will submit to the Horrors of an artificial Famine, with that Tameness which distinguished, Five or Six Years ago, the People of Bengal, in a similar Case.— Men of the most extensive Reading have already observed, that such Patience is not recorded in the historical Page of any other Nation.— If Outrages of this kind begin here, their Progress may extend further than we can imagine; for, to stop it, without Troops, is impossible; and with American Troops, the most enterprizing General, if a systematic Republican, or a Man acquainted with human Nature, will act Cautiously in Stopping the Disorder.

The inclosed Copy of my Letter to General Washington of the 4th: Instant, in Answer to his of the 14th: Ulto. from Middle brook, will give Congress a true Idea of my Opinion, respecting our entering Canada, and the only Route which we can take with reasonable Hopes of Success.— Individuals, and not the Public, will be benefitted by an Expedition into Canada, by either of the Routes from Albany. That of Co’os2 alone is practicable; but not without the Co-operation of the Allied Fleet.—3

If Congress intend that John Brown be executed, their Resolution should be known very soon; or the only Advantage which the United States may reap from avenging Justice, will be lost.— He is in a melancholy Situation, and cannot live long, unless set at full Liberty.— Clemency itself would scarcely be an Act of Beneficence, if retarded.—

The Ten Thousand Dollars in Specie, now in the Hands of General Heath, seem to demand the Attention of Congress. I wrote on that Head, the 29th: of January, but have not yet received any Instructions.— In Justice to General Heath, I entreat your Excellency will inform Congress, that he is very solicitous of being eased of that Burden.—

Captain Banck, the respectable German Officer I mentioned in my Letter of the 3rd: of Decr. inclosing his Memorial, is needlessly maintained at great Expence, without doing any Service.— He might be usefully employed in Count Pulaski’s Corps, or otherwise.— Not to countenance him, would be cruel; for he deserves well of us.—4

General Washington’s Letter of the 14th: of Feby. is enclosed.— It being the only Letter I have received from his Excellency since December, Congress will immediately judge of the Extent, or Limitation which it is proper to Observe in their Instructions to me. I am Sir Your Excellencys most Obedient Servant

Horatio Gates

Honble The Presidt of Congress

ALS, DNA: PCC, item 154, 2: 63–66 (EJ: 10922). Endorsed by Charles Thomson: “. . . Read April 5 / Referred to the board of War.” Enclosures: C of Gates to Washington, 4 Mar. 1779 (Dft in NHi: Gates); C of Washington to Gates, 14 Feb. 1779 (printed in GWF description begins John C. Fitzpatrick, ed., The Writings of George Washington from the Original Manuscript Sources, 1745–1799 (39 vols.; Washington, D.C., 1931–44) description ends , 14: 108–10).

1Gates’s letter of 30 Nov. 1778, with its enclosed memorial from Brigadier General Louis Le Bégue de Presle Duportail (1743–1802), has not been located. Duportail, a French officer, was commandant of the Corps of Engineers in the Continental army. The documents were read in Congress, 31 Dec. 1778, and referred to the Marine Committee. JJ’s reply to Gates’s letter of 30 Nov. simply stated: “I am not authorized to say anything of the Intention of Congress relative to the proposed Fortification at Boston.” JCC description begins Worthington C. Ford et al., eds., Journals of the Continental Congress, 1774–1789 (34 vols.; Washington, D.C., 1904–37) description ends , 12: 1265; JJ to Gates, 4 Apr. 1779, NHi: Gates (EJ: 737).

2Cohoes is at the juncture of the Mohawk and Hudson rivers in New York.

3This paragraph and the concluding paragraph of the letter were copied and sent to Washington in a letter from JJ, 6 Apr. 1779 (DLC: Washington Papers, series 4, EJ: 10380). JJ characterized the letter from which they were extracted as being “in a certain degree interesting.” Washington replied: “Conscious that it is the aim of my actions to promote the public good, and that no part of my conduct is influenced by personal enmity to individuals, I cannot be insensible to the artifice, employed by some men to prejudice me in the public esteem. The circumstance of which you have obliged me with a communication, is among a number of other instances of the unfriendly views which have governed a certain gentleman from a very early period.” See Washington to JJ, 14 Apr., ALS, NNC (EJ: 7232); and JJ’s reply of 21 Apr. 1779, below.

4General Gates’s letter of 3 Dec. 1778 and the memorial of Captain John V. Bancke have not been located. On 10 July 1779 Congress voted to reimburse Bancke for his services to enable him to return to Germany and to allow Gates to employ him as he saw fit until Bancke was able to obtain passage (JCC description begins Worthington C. Ford et al., eds., Journals of the Continental Congress, 1774–1789 (34 vols.; Washington, D.C., 1904–37) description ends , 14: 816). For Gates’s approval of Congress’s action, see his letter to JJ of 25 July 1779, ALS, NHi: Gates (EJ: 792). Count Casimir Pulaski (1749–79), a Polish refugee, served as a dragoon leader until March 1778, when he received congressional approval to raise an independent body of cavalry.

Index Entries