From Caleb Gibbs
Boston 21th April 1799
Having observed a List of appointments in which my name was not inserted has filled me with disquiting apprehensions lest for some reason or other it may be entirely omitted.
Although it was the opinion of some of my friends that I might have rested securely on the honorable testimonials of services during the late war from yourself and other respectable characters which were transmitted [to] the Secretary of War, yet in a matter of so much moment I Judged it expedient to repair to Philadelphia for the purpose of renewing my respects to yourself and Major General Hamilton personally and to endeavour to obtain if not possitive assurances, yet some evidence which would prevent or remove, all uneasiness as to the certainty of an appointment. And in fact such was the sort of approbation I received both from yourself and General Hamilton that all my doubts were removed and I returned to this place impressed with the belief that I should not be neglected. But with the chagrin of having performed an unpleasant and expensive Journey I find that my hopes deceived me.
The state of my mind in consequence of an unsuccessful application supported by the documents of yourself and other officers of rank may be immagined and therefore is unnecessary to be further explained. It is not for me to arraign the policy which has dictated a different choice, a comparison of myself with others is a circumstance too delicate to be made.1
The Regimental engagements having now been compleated in this quarter leave no hope for me to succeed in my wished for expectation. It is therefore my desire if possible to be arranged in the staff. The Deputy Quarter Master General is a place I flatter myself I could discharge with propriety as activity, arrangement and œconomy are the criterion of that department.2
I did myself the honor to visit the President of the United States a few days since, and after recapitulating my disappointment in the Line of the Army, I mentioned to him my ideas respecting this appointment on the staff. he observed to me, that with you Sir as Commander in Chief would orriginate those nominations and advised me without delay to write you on this subject, he expressed a wish to render me every service observing at the same time, that whatever your nominations were he should chearfully coincide in.
Under the circumstance of the case I flatter myself that I may be permitted without offence to appeal to your friendship in Order to obtain the appointment I now solicit3—With the greatest regard respect and esteem I have the honor to be Dear Sir Your most Obedient humble servant
ALS, DLC:GW. An extract of Gibbs’s letter is in DLC: Hamilton Papers.
1. Before receiving this letter from Gibbs on 4 May, GW had twice strongly objected to the rejection of the recommendation made by himself, Alexander Hamilton, and Charles Cotesworth Pinckney in Philadelphia in December 1798 that Gibbs be made commander of one of the Massachusetts regiments in the New Army with the rank of lieutenant colonel (GW to McHenry, 25 Mar., 23 April). For the reasons advanced for Gibbs’s rejection, see note 1 of GW’s letter to McHenry of 25 March.
2. For the names of the Massachusetts officers who were given recruiting assignments in April 1799, see the enclosure in Nathan Rice to Hamilton, 28 April 1799 (Syrett, Hamilton Papers, description begins Harold C. Syrett et al., eds. The Papers of Alexander Hamilton. 27 vols. New York, 1961–87. description ends 23:81–84).
3. GW replied on 5 May: “Dear Sir, By yesterday’s Mail I received your letter of the 21st Ulto.
“It is with others (if they are disposed to do it) and not for me, to account for the disappointment of your Military expectation. Your name was in the arrangement handed to the Department of War; beyond this, you, probably, can obtain better information than it is in my power to give. But it would be uncandid after saying thus much, not to add that, it would comport neither with propriety, nor with my practice, to bring you forward again.
“If the President is disposed to serve you, in addition to the Letters of recommendation with which you appeared at Phila., he has the evidence of my opinion of your Services, in the arrangement above mentioned. With esteem—I am Dear Sir Your Obedient Hble Servt Go: Washington” (letterpress copy, DLC:GW). Gibbs also wrote Hamilton on 25 April, enclosing two copies of an extract that he had made from this letter to GW.