From John C. Ogden
Septr 20th 1798
More than ten years have elapsed, since from time to time, I have most respectfully and circumstantially, stated the doings of Calvinists in The United States, in their concerted endeavors to defeat that liberty, toleration and protection in religion, which our laws establish, and upon which our national honor, happiness and safety depend.1
The moderation, caution, prudence, polite & respectful attention paid by you, and other leaders of every faith (except the Calvinists) to our religious rights, have been abused and perverted by this party, to the purposes of sacrilege, infidelity and sedition.
These assertions are serious and true. The Church in every part of The States, has been pillaged. Laws exist in the northern and eastern States, which subvert universal toleration and safety.
Colleges endowed, founded, and supported by all denominations and from public money, are seized upon, for the private purposes of ambitious men.
Prejudices are circulated from Colleges and pulpits, which constantly excite feuds, and perpetuate usurpations.
Concerts of prayer, missions, and projects to urge on the millenium, are improved and abused, by ecclesiastical tyrants.
To obtain this system, the Calvinists opposed Great Britain, thirty years ago. To secure it since our establishing of independence, the late peace, and a new government, all the artillery of prejudice, misrepresentation—pulpits, colleges and confederations of Calvinists have been directed.
The world will look to all conscientious christians and churchmen to decide whether these things are proper. Printed statements have been circulated, which may be confirmed by public records.
As a professor of Christianity, and a churchman, Your Excellency can decide, whether you embarked in the revolution to give undue power to any body of men, over the consciences of your self or others. Whether you expected or can justify the plunderings of the church, the usurpations of the colleges and the injuries done from thence, to the community to which you belong, or the families of these whose fathers, brothers, & sons fell in the late war.
During life, and after death, your contemporaries and our posterity will seek for General Washingtons opinions and procedure, after these wrongs. In them are contained perpetual sources for feuds and confusions.
It is not decent for us to solicit your opinion. It would however gratify the church and your countrymen to have it. In civil office, your influence and safety would have been in danger. But at the head of a new army, or as a private man, the opportunity now presents for you to speak.
Death and the world where justice reigns are fast approaching. No duty can be more worthy of your attention than this, while heaven lengthens out your valuable life. Copies of this letter will be forwarded without delay to Presidents Adams & Jefferson, to the Governors of the States, and heads of literary, ecclesiastical and other departments.
Those who have been honored by you in war and in civil stations, with proofs of distinguished politeness, confidence, and partiality, have been the chief agents in these nefarious procedures. These usurpations and their abettors are too publicly known to be forgotten, and too many in every part of the States, are selecting every ⟨occurence⟩ for the records of historians, for us to expect that such transactions will pass into oblivion, or such practices be viewed as harmless and inoffensive. With the highest veneration for my country’s guardian and friend I have the honor to be your devoted servant
John C. Ogden
John Cosens Ogden (1751–1800) was an Episcopal clergyman in Portsmouth, N.H., from 1786 until his retirement in 1797, after his mind had become “deranged” (Harrison, Princetonians, 1769–1775, description begins Richard A. Harrison. Princetonians, 1769–1775: A Biographical Dictionary. Princeton, N.J., 1980. description ends 93–97).
1. Between 30 Oct. 1789 and 26 Nov. 1796 Ogden wrote to GW nine times. He resumed writing to GW on 4 Sept. 1798 and continued writing to him until June 1799. Tobias Lear’s acknowledgment on 4 Feb. 1790 of Ogden’s letter of 20 Jan. 1790 is the only response to any of Ogden’s letters that has been found. Ogden’s letter to GW of 4 Sept. 1798 begins: “How far you ever condescend to second such requests as the following to Governor Jay, I cannot tell. If it is consistent with your line of proceeding I know that I have only to hint at the favor.” Ogden followed this with a copy of his letter of the same date to Gov. John Jay of New York. Ogden asked Jay to help him secure the post of collector of the customs at New Haven, Conn., upon the fast approaching death of the present collector. For good measure, Ogden enclosed in his letter to GW of 4 Sept. copies of two other letters that he had written to Jay, one dated 17 Aug. and the other 29 Aug. 1798. On 1 Nov. Ogden wrote GW about the recent struggle of the Episcopalians in New Hampshire and Vermont with the “Calvinists,” and then on 12 Feb. 1799 he wrote from “Prison” in Litchfield, Connecticut. It was Oliver Wolcott, Jr., he wrote, who had “cast” him into prison “for a small sum due honestly to him.” Wolcott had done this, Ogden explained, because he wished to have the post of New Haven collector of the customs, to which Ogden aspired, for a relative and also because Wolcott had “joined with the church plunderers in Portsmouth to destroy” him. In his final two letters to GW, dated 13 May and 17 June 1799, Ogden wrote about his continued persecution and the continuing misdeeds of the Calvinists. Ogden’s letters to GW are in DLC:GW.