To James Madison
Mount Vernon Augt 17[–18]th 1788.
My dear Sir,
Although the letter of Mr Pleasants and its enclosure will appear under date of the 25th of July, it never got to my hand till friday last. Tomorrow is the first Post by which I could forward it. It is now sent with thanks for the perusal. I shall write to the Count de Moustier, but in pretty general terms—giving the substance rather than the detail of this business.1
That the circular letter from the Convention of New York should be handed to the public as the unanimous sense of that body is, to me, surprizing. It will, I fear, be attended with pernicious consequences. The decision of North Carolina—unaccountable as it is—is not, in my opinion, more to be regretted.2 With sentiments of the highest esteem & regard—I am—My dear Sir Yr Most Obedient and Affectionate Hble Servt
I had written this letter, but had not sent it to the Post-Office, when your favor of the 11th was brought to me.
I am clearly in sentiment with you that the longer the question respecting the permanent Seat of Congress remains unagitated, the greater certainty there will be of its fixture in a central spot. But not having the same means of information and judging that you have; it would have been a moot point with me, whether a temporary Residence of that body at New York would not have been a less likely mean of keeping it ultimately from the center (being farther removed from it) than if it was to be at Philada, because, in proportion as you draw it to the center, you lessen the inconveniences and of course the solicitude of the Southern & Western extremities; and when to these are super-added the acquaintances and connections which naturally will be formed—the expences which more than probably will be incurred for the accomodation of the public Offices—with a long train of etceteras, it might be found an arduous task to approach nearer to the Axis there after. These, however, are first thoughts; and may not go to the true principles of policy which governs in this case. I am as before Yrs very sincerely
ALS, NN: Berg Collection; LB, DLC:GW.
1. For the French minister’s query about American trade and other matters and the responses of GW and Madison, see Thomas Pleasants, Jr., to GW, 25 July, n.2, and GW to Moustier, 26 Mar., n.3., and 17 August.
2. For the New York circular letter, see Madison to GW, 11 Aug., n.2. In the North Carolina convention no vote on ratification was taken; instead, the Antifederalists passed by a vote of 184–84 a proposal for a declaration of rights of twenty articles as well as twenty-six proposed amendments to the Constitution. The proposed amendments were to be submitted to Congress and to a new convention of states to be called for the purpose of amending the Constitution (Delbert Harold Gilpatrick, Jeffersonian Democracy in North Carolina, 1789–1816 [New York, 1967], 33).