To Thomas Jefferson
Mount Vernon April 8th 1784.
If with frankness, and the fullest latitude of a friend, you will give me your opinion of the Institution of the Society of Cincinnati, it would confer an acceptable favor upon me.1 If to this opinion, you would be so obliging as to add the Sentiments, or what you suppose to be the Sentiments of Congress respecting it, I would thank you.
That you may have the best Materials on which to form a judgment, I send you a copy of the proceedings of the Society.2 Consequent of their choice of me for Presidt Pro Tem and the direction therein, I sent the Institution to the French land & Naval Commanders—and to the Marqs de la Fayette—as the Senr French Officer in the American Army—whose proceedings thereon I also enclose to you.3
These Papers you will please to retain (for fear of accidents) ’till I shall have the pleasure (the Week after next) of seeing you in Annapolis on my way to Philadelphia; whither this, & other business, will take me; but the sooner I could receive your sentiments on this Subject, the more pleasing they would be to me.
The Pamphlet ascribed to Mr Burke, has I am told had its effect. People are alarmed, especially in the Eastern States.4 How justly, or how contrary to the avowed principles of the Society and the purity of their motives, I will not declare, least it should appear that I wanted to biass your judgment rather than to obtain an opinion—which, if you please, might be accompanied with sentiments (under the information here given) respecting the most eligable measures to be pursued by the Society at their next meeting.5
You may be assured Sir, that to the good opinion, alone, which I entertain of your abilities & candor, this liberty is to be attributed; and I can truly add, that with very great esteem & regard I am—Dr Sir Yr most obt & Hble Servt
P.S. I was on the point of closing this Letter, when Mr Hogendorff put your favor of the 6th into my hands.
ALS, DLC: Jefferson Papers; LB, DLC:GW.
1. For the extent of GW’s involvement in the Society of the Cincinnati before this time, see the editorial note in General Meeting of the Society of the Cincinnati, 4–18 May 1784.
2. The Institution includes the record of the proceedings in establishing the Society of the Cincinnati on 10 and 13 May 1783 and the minutes of its first meeting on 19 June 1783. The Institution is printed in Hume, Society of the Cincinnati, description begins Edgar Erskine Hume, ed. General Washington’s Correspondence concerning the Society of the Cincinnati. Baltimore, 1941. description ends 1–14.
3. There is nothing in the minutes of the meeting of 19 June 1783 when GW was elected president to indicate that he was given a “direction” to send copies of the Institution to the Frenchmen. For GW’s doing so, see GW to Knox, 16 Oct. 1783, to Rochambeau and to Gérard, both 29 Oct., and to Lafayette, 30 Oct. 1783. GW had received a number of letters from the French officers reporting on the reception of the society in France; which of these he sent to Jefferson has not been determined.
5. Jefferson’s reply is dated 16 April.