Address on the Jay Treaty1
[New York, July 30, 1795. “Mr. Hamilton said, ‘unless the treaty was ratified, we might expect a foreign war, and if it is ratified we might expect a civil war.’ He adds, ‘true, a gentleman observed to me, that a foreign war might be procrastinated by further negociations, but this would be degrading to the honor of the nation.’ To this he added, although not in direct terms, yet such as purported to every hearer, that, of the alternative (of foreign or civil war) he would chuse the latter…. In the course of his speech, after having reprobated as uncertain and fraudulent the means hitherto used (viz.) the assembling of the populace, he proposed several methods in order to ‘obtain the true sense of the people, which had not been done, although asserted to have been.’ One of the proposals was, ‘to go round in the several wards of the city to the people individually.’ He adds, ‘we will let the question respecting the treaty, rest in the constitutional authority, and put the question to the people, are you for or against the constitutional authorities!’” The text of this speech has not been found.]
The [New York] Argus, or Greenleaf’s New Daily Advertiser, August 13, 1795.
1. This report of H’s speech on the Jay Treaty was submitted to the Argus by “J.H.” In introducing his summary of H’s speech, “J.H.” wrote: “On Friday evening of the 30th ult. I attended the Convention at the Assembly Room in William-street, in order to hear Mr. Hamilton’s discussion on the treaty. Mr. Hamilton opened the meeting with a long harrangue of aspersions, reflections and animadversions upon the assembling and proceedings of the rabble, and upon an association of men who have been termed a ‘self created society.’ I have thought proper to lay a few of the most extraordinary expressions before the public.”